FRANKLIN COUNTY — The number of Vermonters dying from opioid overdoses doubled since 2019. Meanwhile, inflated food prices and expensive housing costs squeeze household budgets.
Right when police are needed most, how much can taxpayers afford?
Three years after widespread calls to re-examine policing models nationwide, the county’s two municipal police departments – St. Albans and Swanton – are looking at instituting some major upgrades to tackle new drug problems.
But what would such expansions really do? Would they fix the local drug crisis currently facing residents? Or is it just another Band-aid for what’s causing the state’s drug problems in the first place?
In St. Albans, the City of St. Albans proposed its first budget for a joint police department this past week, which would add four more uniformed officers and a two-person street crimes unit to SAPD operations in order to expand coverage.
The expected cost – if approved as presented – would add another roughly $1 million to the town’s police budget, up to $2.4 million from the $1.4 million budgeted last year to cover the town’s lapsing contract with the Franklin County Sheriff’s Office
A few miles north in Swanton, the Village of Swanton is starting discussions with the town selectboard next week to see if town residents would be willing to become a foundational partner in the expansion of the Swanton Police Department.
Details about what such a partnership would look like are still being hashed out, but Swanton Village is already on course to establish a new expanded building for the department as part of the administration’s efforts to add more space for village operations.
Municipal officials from both areas point to the region’s growing drug problems as a large variable driving each decision. Both efforts, however, will take millions of dollars over several years to bring to fruition.
“Running a police department is expensive. There’s no other way about it,” Swanton Town Administrator Brian Savage said.
But in rural Franklin County, adding new taxes could be a hard sell.
Vermont’s cost-of-living was high before the COVID-19 pandemic, but inflation and housing costs have been a hard one-two punch for many households on the lower rungs of the socioeconomic ladder, including older people on fixed incomes. The state’s median household income actually decreased by $4,000 between 2021 and 2022, when inflation is considered in the equation.
Meanwhile, local budgets keep going up. As municipal expenditures are affected by inflation, town and city administrators have largely forged ahead with multiple expansionary initiatives they’ve argued are necessary.
In recent years, such initiatives include St. Albans City’s wide-ranging efforts to flip the downtown over the last decade, create in-fill development and beef up its housing stock. Nearby, the Town of St. Albans completed the construction of a public works building and new town hall in the same time span, while Swanton village and town are both in the midst of planning new buildings. Further out in more rural areas, local governments, such as Highgate and Montgomery, are eyeing downtown redevelopment projects and build outs of water and sewer infrastructure.
Each step, however, has created some growing pains. As Vermont attracts more people, urbanization brings its own issues, like crime.
According to an analysis of U.S. Census data by Vermont Treasurer’s Office, more people moved to the state in the last two years than the previous ten-year-period.
“With a growing community, we need a top notch police force that’s going to be worth what we pay for it, but it’s going to be a lot of money,” Town Manager Sean Adkins said.
For Melinda White, who’s fought her own hard drug addictions, the monetary cost of helping someone isn’t much of a consideration.
“Talk to someone who lost a loved one to addiction, they don’t care what it costs,” she said.
White now works as a social worker for Turning Point (as well as a few other social service organizations), and she serves as a member of the police advisory board for the City of St. Albans.
She strongly supports bringing back the police department’s street crimes unit, which had been disbanded in 2020 due to budget cuts.
In operation, the street crimes unit consists of two undercover individuals able to track illegal drug buys throughout the community, but they also play a larger role, White said. Because street crimes officers are often interfacing directly with the individuals in need of help, they can serve as a bridge between those suffering from substance abuse and social services.
The process is usually a long one, White said. When an officer first reaches out to someone in need, they’re usually not receptive, but such contacts create “a seed,” White said. Over time, when people recognize that they need help, they’ll make a call.
White said she’s had calls from people months after an officer passes along her contact info to someone suffering from substance abuse.
Mental health clinician Samantha Weber has seen similar situations. As one of two mental health specialists working directly with the St. Albans Police Department, Weber said law enforcement’s role can be a positive one when paired with a network of social services working in conjunction.
“The reality is it’s not the first time that I see somebody that I’m getting a ‘yes.’ It’s repeat exposure and repeat contact,” she said.
St. Albans Police Chief Maurice Lamothe said via email that the street crimes unit was also effective in putting away predatory drug dealers. When the unit was active, drug arrests were close to nine times higher than they have been in the last two years.
Due to the lack of enforcement overtime, Lamothe said drug dealers have been effective in finding toeholds in the community by threatening people into submission and occupying a “territory” until police can organize raids. In theory, the street crime unit would give the department extra capacity to go after these networks.
“As soon as we stopped (the SCU), we saw a resurgence coming back in. Now back together again, we’re hoping that we can return to those staffing levels,” City Manager Dominic Cloud said.
White said there’s also a need for the street crimes unit to tamp down on new dangerous drugs coming into St. Albans. In the 2010s, fentanyl was making its way into illegal opioids to increase the potency, but these days, xylazine, or Tranq, has become its cheaper alternative.
In its untreated form, the drug is used as a horse tranquilizer, but when used by people, it puts addicts into deep sleeps that can last hours or even days. For repeat users, it also creates lesions on the skin by causing necrosis.
Tranq has already flooded illegal drug marketplaces in Philadelphia and New York City, and it’s becoming more prevalent in Vermont. About one-third of opioid deaths in Vermont this year were tainted with the drug.
“We are in such a huge crisis right now,” White said. “We keep losing patient after patient to addiction, and the potency of the drugs right now puts us in a crisis more than ever. The street crimes unit can help reduce death.”
As both Swanton Village and St. Albans City taxpayers already cover the costs of policing for their departments, most of the related expansionary cost burden of regionalization would be felt by neighboring municipalities. The Town of St. Albans, for example, is already locked into an agreement to help cover those costs for the city’s expansion, but there’s still wiggle room to adjust what the final number will be.
Town of St. Albans Selectboard members discussed their early points of view briefly during their meeting last Monday, where they expressed some apprehension about the price point.
“This $2.4 million, I don’t find it to be acceptable, for the record,” selectboard member Brendan Deso said.
The board also questioned how effective more policing would be overall. If local St. Albans police tackle local drug markets, that doesn’t necessarily mean they disappear. After raiding one location, drug houses can pop up in another place further away, thereby inconveniencing other Franklin County towns.
It’s also unclear how the impact of expanding police services would be felt by the larger legal and law enforcement systems. The Franklin County criminal court system is already dealing with a backlog of cases prompted by the COVID-19 pandemic. The Franklin County Sheriff’s Office has also typically fulfilled the role as the county’s regional policing service, and having multiple agencies compete for the same staffing can push up salary costs.
Selectboard member Jonathan Giroux also questioned the efficacy of adding more police when the problems causing drug use often go much deeper. Despite such concerns, the selectboard agreed that something needs to be done.
Policing may not be the end-all solution – but like questions about budgets – it’s application can spark a larger discussion.
“The first budget meeting we had for the police board wasn’t the final one,” Selectboard Chair Bryan DesLauriers said. “There’ll be more than one. I’m being very conservative in my guess.”
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here