FRANKLIN COUNTY — Reporters often have opportunities to try new things, but I had no desire to get Bolawrap’d last Friday.
“You’re going to get wrapped,” Cpl. Nicholas Palmier yelled out to WCAX reporter Cam Smith in the side yard of the Franklin County Sheriff’s Department.
One loud shot later, Smith’s legs were bound by a seven-foot strand of kevlar rope.
It’s been a year since Vermont journalists widely reported on Sheriff John Grismore’s ongoing simple assault charge, and here was one of them voluntarily wrapped in the sheriff’s side yard, with another waiting in the wings.
“If you did it, I guess I have to,” NBC5 reporter Amanda Martin-Ryan said to Smith as she framed up the shot.
It’s been a rocky year for Sheriff John Grismore. He was running for the sheriff seat in the summer of 2022 when a video of him kicking a man in custody went gangbusters on the Internet, and a year later, he’s facing questions of financial improprieties, as his office is investigated by Vermont legislators on the House’s impeachment committee.
But after all that, there’s a chance Grismore could walk away from his challenges unscathed.
The verdict isn’t out yet, but come Oct. 17, the use of force case that largely started his time under public scrutiny is being heard in front of the Vermont Criminal Justice Council.
Under one outcome, the VCJC could revoke Grismore’s law enforcement certification, essentially removing him from office. Or the VCJC could rule that his use of force was within acceptable bounds, redefining the earlier public reaction as overblown.
Either way, the decision changes what comes next.
There’s been a lot of ups and downs about the Grismore case, but I first interviewed him after he won the election for sheriff last December. Grismore hadn’t been sworn into office yet, but he was laying the groundwork by meeting with his fellow employees and gathering support for his efforts.
He also told me about his first reaction when the video first broke last summer and changed his reputation. Here’s an excerpt.
–
‘“It was the most horrible thing I’ve ever experienced in my life,” Grismore told the Messenger. “My son saw it. He calls my mom in a panic because he knows nothing. I hadn’t even had time to digest what was going on.”
Instead of rolling out his plans for the Franklin County Sheriff’s Office, Grismore found his name was now making the rounds in the national media, garnering thousands of clicks and prompting hateful comments on social media from people he didn’t know.
Both local political parties asked him to step down from the race. He was fired from his job as the office’s chief deputy, and in the months ahead, he was charged with simple assault, which is still unresolved in the courts. …
“It would have been a lot easier for me to walk away,” he said. “And a lot of people in my camp were saying, ‘Just walk away, John. Just walk away from this. If you really want to make this go away, just withdraw. And it took a little time – not a lot of time – but a little time to kind of understand it for myself and see if this is really what I wanted.”’
—
In the resulting months, Grismore hasn’t stepped down, but his story has continued. By last spring, the Vermont House of Representatives had launched its investigation into his office, but back in Franklin County, he’s continued to rally support.
According to Grismore, he’s found plenty among colleagues and co-workers who see statewide forces arrayed against him. By the way he tells his story, both the media and the Vermont statehouse overplayed the seriousness of the situation in an attempt to remove him from office.
Although I don’t agree with every point, Grismore’s story is a compelling one. At a time when the public’s expectations for police are shifting, he’s standing at the intersection of a lot of different institutional pressures as the state takes a close look at how he runs his office.
Overall trust in law enforcement, for example, deteriorated following the George Floyd protests while both workforce shortages and inflation increased the cost of providing law enforcement services. Grismore, meanwhile, has had the added responsibility of convincing reticent taxpayers that the Franklin County Sheriff’s Office is keeping them safe. Add all of his personal challenges to the top, and it’s quite a mix of varying responsibilities that don’t always meld.
“Some people say that I ought to write a book,” he said.
While I‘m not sure if he’s picked up a pen, Grismore is actively trying to get his story out there. As the statehouse refocuses its impeachment inquiry, the Franklin County Sheriff has met with various publications within Vermont’s media landscape, laying out his viewpoint and providing his own insights into how it all played out since the video of his kick went viral.
This past August, he talked at length with VTDigger’s Shaun Robinson to look at the events that impacted his life last year, and he made regular appearances on WCAX this past summer to argue a few public points, including one challenging state Rep. Mike McCarthy (D-St. Albans City).
A recent Northwest Access TV interview by Richard Cowperthwait earlier this summer also gave Grismore an open venue to discuss a wide-ranging set of topics that didn’t always focus on his legal troubles.
Then there’s me. The Messenger has also done its fair share of coverage of Grismore, written primarily by yours truly. I’ve worked to respect his position as sheriff while also being cognizant of what’s happening at the statehouse.
But I also recognize that there’s a larger story here.
While questions remain about Grismore’s use of force, the fact that it happened caused major institutional reactions during a time when players in law enforcement, media and government all are trying to shore up foundational challenges to their livelihoods.
The House Special Committee on Impeachment met for the first time in a month on Sept. 20. The seven-member group was created to investigate the operations of both former Franklin County State’s Attorney John Lavoie and the Franklin County Sheriff’s Office, and they’ve recently switched gears to focus on Grismore now that Lavoie has resigned.
The committee met with use of force experts, Kim McManus and Michael Akerlind, on Wednesday.
McManus reviewed the state’s policy on use of force. The 33-page document defines the various terms and approaches recommended by the state, but she emphasized one sentence in the policy statement to clarify Vermont’s position.
“When force is necessary to bring an event or incident under control, officers will use only objectively reasonable force to accomplish lawful objectives.”
So what’s “objectively reasonable force?”
Akerlind, who trains new officers on use of force, provided the answer. He explained there are four aspects weighed when determining what’s reasonable use of force, and they are the severity of the crime, the threat of the subject, the subject’s resistance and the larger situation.
He said there’s also some leeway granted when looking at use of force cases after the fact. If a situation is evolving quickly and dynamically, for example, there’s less of an expectation when looking back that every move made by an officer will be perfect, he said.
State Rep. McCarthy followed up with another question – what’s stopping an officer from not following policy?
“It comes back to the core tenet of what we do as law enforcement officers. It’s based on our integrity and the fact that people believe we tell the truth. When I write an affidavit and send it to the court, the court is recognizing that what I put in that affidavit is the truth. That integrity is one of the core values of being a law enforcement officer,” Akerlind said. “If an officer can’t maintain that, it calls into question everything that we do.“
“It boils down to common sense, but here we are,” McCarthy replied.
“When I came into the office, it became a priority to invest in tech,” Grismore said last Friday, standing behind a podium and talking to reporters.
I sat off-camera. The other two television reporters had set up a little farther away after equipping Grismore with microphones.
After reading the press release earlier in the day, I already had an idea of what Grismore wanted to say. A quick Google search told me that law enforcement agencies across the country had already invested in the Bolawrap as the latest in non-lethal takedowns. The general connection to Grismore’s use-of-force case wasn’t lost to me either.
Over the next five minutes from behind the podium, Grismore explained the sheriff’s office's approach. Two corporals had been trained in Bolawrap use, and in 18 months, the rest of the staff would have one at a cost of $1,300 per device and $40 per shot.
If one use could save a life or reduce harm, then it was worth the investment, Grismore said. Unlike tasers, the Bolawrap causes no pain, and if deployed correctly, it could help officers get control of a suspect quickly and efficiently by allowing them to move in.
The Bolawrap comes with limitations, of course. Its use isn’t recommended on older or pregnant people, or on children. Also, If someone has their arms or legs out, the rope could have a harder time wrapping around a subject.
Smith, however, asked the million dollar question. Is the Bolawrap purchase connected to Grismore’s use-of-force case?
“Let’s not muddy the waters,” Grismore replied.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here