Early budget talks for expanded St. Albans Police Department set cost at $4.8M; Includes $1M increase in policing costs for town

Posted

ST. ALBANS — Now that St. Albans City and St. Albans Town have decided to partner to provide policing services, the bills are coming due. 

The first draft budget for the new and improved St. Albans Police Department was released this week following the first meeting of the joint police board – a team of six representatives split between the city and town. 

The expected cost to run the new department – offset by $500,000 in operating revenues – is just over $4.8 million. Splitting the cost down the middle, $2.4 million would be covered by city taxpayers, and for the first time in three years, the second half – the other $2.4 million – would be covered by town taxpayers.

“This budget proposal it’s responsive to run a 21st century police department,” City Manager Dominic Cloud said. “It’s responsive to the type of department that (residents) deserve.”

Initial agreement

The first meeting of the joint police board has been a long time coming. Officials from St. Albans Town and City signed the initial agreement to join forces on providing policing back in January of 2023 as part of a larger package between the two entities over water/sewer service.

It also helped defuse some growing tension between the city and town.

Prior to January, the city was enforcing its “affiliation fee” that attached a recurring annual payment, to be made to the city, onto any new builds outside its limits looking to hook into the city’s water network. 

Town officials called it an out-of-jurisdiction tax restricting growth. City officials labeled it as the cost of doing business.

The joint agreement, however, nixed the fee completely, resetting the relationship between the two neighboring municipal governments in exchange for police coverage.

Now, the finer details of the agreement – the actual police budget – are being worked out by the joint police board. 

City representatives include city councilors Tim Hawkins, Bob Farrar and Trudy Cioffi. The three-member group functions as the city council’s finance committee.

Town representatives include selectboard chair Bryan DesLauriers, selectboard vice chair Jack Brigham and interim director of operations Al Voegele. 

The numbers

Of the expenditures expected, the largest cost driver in the draft budget, by far, are police wages. 

Under the agreement, the city agreed to hire four new police officers in order to adequately cover the town, bringing the total up to 16 uniformed officers, two crisis specialists as well as potentially two undercover officers.

With the expanded staffing, wage expenses have been set at $2.5 million, with employee benefits adding another $900,000 into the mix.

Last year, those two costs were $1.65 million and $600,000, respectively.

Cloud said the department also expects to re-institute its narcotics unit. Three years ago, when the town contracted its policing services with the Franklin County Sheriff’s Office, the city disbanded the unit.

Since then, Cloud said there’s been a re-occurrence of drug activity in St. Albans, and the newly re-formed unit, consisting of two undercover police officers, should help crack down on the emergence of drug houses popping up in St. Albans. 

It’s also getting a new name. Before, the narcotics unit was known as the “Street crimes” unit.

“(Street crimes) was really effective at pushing all that drug activity out of the city and town. As soon as we stopped it, we saw a resurgence coming back in. Now back together again, we’re hoping that we can return to those staffing levels,” Cloud said.

The city’s proposed budget also includes a $630,000 expense under a dispatch line item. While there’s a separate dispatch department run by the city, Cloud said the additional expense included in the police department budget was added to track the time and resources used by other departments that are required to run both police and dispatch.

“There’s all kinds of costs, that when it was just us, didn’t need to be a part of the police department budget,” Cloud said. 

Normally, such cost centers would have been folded into other departmental budgets, but since the town is helping to cover the total costs of providing police services, they had to be identified and included. Cloud named general liability insurance–important for officers entering sometimes dangerous situations – within the larger insurance package purchased for city employees as an example.

As for changes over previous years, one of the quickly expanding cost centers in the police budget include professional and purchased services for the department. In 2019, the city paid $76,000 to outside consultants to tackle IT issues, snow removal, uniform cleaning as well as background checks.

Five years later, the city expects to pay over $300,000 to outside professional services. 

Cloud said the biggest cost driver for the additional spend has been IT work related to body cameras for each officer. Since data is required to be backed up for six years, that means the city requires a lot of data storage space to store the video generated by the police body cameras, which has inflated costs.

Town impacts

For town residents, the $2.4 million price tag of covering half of the St. Albans Police budget will be a substantial increase compared to last year’s cost of policing services. Last year’s contract with the Franklin County Sheriff’s Office cost $1.4 million for the town.

City residents, however, will see a slight reduction over last year’s costs. For city taxpayers, the police budget was $2.5 million last year, and despite the expansion of services, they should see a reduction of $90,000 in the total costs required for the police department.

While the increase could lead to some sticker shock for some town residents, Town Manager Sean Adkins said the $1 million increase for the town will need to be discussed in more detail by the selectboard to figure out how the town expects to absorb the cost in the town’s own $6.2 million budget.

Last year, voters approved a close to 8% increase in property tax rates for town taxpayers, prompting some negative feedback from residents already struggling on a fixed income due to inflationary pressures. Another rate increase of a similar percentage, however, could be a difficult sell. 

Adkins recognized as much, but he said joining forces with the city for police coverage was “a no-brainer” for him.  

“It’s important that we have all these services, so it’s really a matter of how do we get this to work,” he said. “It’s really about getting the community to see the value in it.”

With the agreement signed, the town is also contractually obligated to cover the final bill, which means there’s little to no option to find an alternative police service at a lower cost. The agreement signed by the city and town also sets out a ten-year-period where the town is essentially locked into working with the city to meet its obligation. 

Adkins is also reluctant to think that the town could find a police service at a much cheaper rate than what the city is proposing to bring to the town. The $1.4 million contract with the sheriff’s office was signed pre-Covid-19 pandemic, and since then, the cost of policing services has increased dramatically.

“Truth be told, I don’t think it would have been a much lower number if we went out to bid,” Adkins said.

That doesn’t mean there’s no way to reduce the $2.4 million cost. The joint police board plans to meet again on Nov. 15 to continue budget discussions around the town’s portion.

Adkins said the selectboard will also be discussing at their next meeting this Monday, Nov. 6, how the proposed police budget impacts the town’s own operations, as it’ll be the selectboard’s decision on finding a way to move forward.

“With a growing community, we need a top notch police force that’s going to be worth what we pay for it, but it’s going to be a lot of money,” Adkins said. 

Note: The first draft of the police budget can be downloaded below.

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here