NORTH HERO — Franklin County Sheriff John Grismore’s trial ended with a hung jury.
After three days of testimony, two years of political tug-of-war, resolutions from state actors, hundreds of news stories, investigations by an impeachment committee, five hours of jury deliberation and hundreds of thousands of dollars of both private and public funds funneled in attorney’s pockets, the jury exited its chambers in the Grand Isle County Courthouse at around 11:15 p.m. this past Wednesday night and delivered its findings.
Did Sheriff Grismore commit simple assault by kicking, and/or foot-pushing, Jeremy Burrows while in police custody back on Aug. 7, 2022?
The jury couldn’t agree on one answer, leading to a mistrial.
Before sending the jury into deliberations, Grand Isle Judge Samuel Hoar’s instructions laid out the charge: Simple Assault. Did Grismore recklessly cause bodily harm? To be true, Grismore would have to be involved. Did he act recklessly? And did it cause bodily harm?
In the three days prior, the two attorneys spent a lot of time diving into those issues, as they tried to clear a logical path for the jury to find the answer.
Grismore was represented by Robert Kaplan, a well-known trial attorney in Vermont. Grand Isle County State’s Attorney Doug DiSabito represented the state. Over the last three days, the two men questioned multiple eyewitnesses, including Grismore and Burrows, as well as two contradicting use-force experts – Thomas Aveni and Eric Daigle – to discuss Grismore’s actions on Aug. 7.
Jury members also had their own viewpoint into the room. The video that started it all – captured by a deputy’s body cam – was watched repeatedly by jury members. At around 9:30 p.m. during the night’s deliberations, the jury requested to watch the four-minute clip depicting the day’s events twice at full volume, and a few seemingly left the room with a little more confidence.
The trial, however, ended up hyper-focusing on two aspects of the charge. Not even Grismore contested that he was the primary actor. But was his strike reckless? Did it hurt Mr. Burrows?
The two sides’ themes emerged during their final arguments. The prosecution argued Grismore did act recklessly. He wasn’t on-duty, and he stepped in when he wasn’t needed to hurt someone in the state’s custody.
“This case is exactly what you thought you saw at first. You can believe your own eyes,” DiSabito said during his closing remarks.
For the defense, however, Grismore's actions couldn't have been reckless. According to its arguments, he was a career law enforcement official with decades of experience stepping up to help his subordinates deal with a belligerent drunk.
“Sometimes, firmness is what’s required, and that’s what happened here,” Kaplan countered.
What happens next for Grismore is still up in the air. Judge Hoar signaled an intention for a second trial at the end of the night, but there’s no date on the calendar.
For Grismore though, the trial ends just a week before the two-year anniversary of when all of this started.
The actual incident which prompted the case happened back on Aug. 7, 2022, but Grismore’s problems quickly spiraled into something much bigger after bodycam footage of the “kick heard round the world” went public. Then-Capt. Grismore was the office’s chief deputy at the time, and the subsequent negative attention that happened as a result of the video came right when he was gearing up to run for sheriff.
During his own testimony this week, Grismore explained he had some political suspicions at the time.
When former sheriff Roger Langevin signaled his intention to leave the office, Grismore said he decided to pursue the seat, but there had been some fractures within the department. While Grismore was chief deputy, he had started to butt heads with Langevin more and more over staffing decisions – including one over deputy Lt. Mark Lauer – but he wanted to stay to help develop the office.
“I think (Langevin) continually saw me as an antagonist, somebody that wasn’t going to go along with him for the sake of going along with him, so that continued to erode our relationship even further,” Grismore said.
The department at the time, Grismore explained, had been hiring more inexperienced deputies to fill out the rolls, and he felt compelled to help out.
The video, however, hurt his chances. Lauer then jumped into the race.
Despite the challenge, Grismore won the seat as sheriff months later in November 2022. Meanwhile, state officials began putting wheels in motion on three different fronts to convince him to step down from the role.
On the first front, the House Special Committee on Impeachment launched in spring, bundling an investigation into his office with one looking into the Franklin County State’s Attorney’s Office. Employees under John Lavoie had filed complaints citing irresponsible comments made throughout his career, and Lavoie ended up leaving his seat months later when they came to light.
Grismore, however, stayed in his position, even after the house committee spent $87,000 on a Burlington legal firm to look into supposed financial irregularities. The findings, however, weren’t substantial enough to serve as a foundation for a longer impeachment trial.
The House later signed a resolution trying to get Grismore to vacate the seat on his own impetus. They also passed a law that cuts the pay of sheriffs who don’t have law enforcement certifications.
On that second front, complaints filed to the Vermont Criminal Justice Council resulted in the de-certification of Grismore’s law enforcement license on the findings that he mis-used the state’s use-of-force policy by striking Burrows. The move effectively removed him from the department’s patrol efforts (and uniquely cut his pay), although he’s still allowed to perform administrative functions.
The third front culminated in Wednesday’s trial. Grand Isle State’s Attorney Doug DiSibato agreed to take up the case back in October 2022, eventually bringing it out to North Hero for the three-day trial.
This time though, Grismore seems to have found advocates on the jury.
If found guilty, Grismore could be sentenced up to a year in prison, or a $1,000 fine.
DiSabito’s prosecution efforts focused much more on the day’s events than Grismore’s defense, and his line of questioning during his cross-examination of Grismore – completed Wednesday morning – kept returning to questions around Grismore’s specific actions in the moment.
Back on Aug. 7, Grismore initially entered the scene after Burrows stood up and began to threaten a deputy, Chris Major. Grismore’s subsequent foot-strike – described as a thrust, a “distractionary front kick, a push, a placement, etc. etc.” – resulted after Grismore said Burrows prepared to spit on his face.
“If you were worried Burrows was about to spit, why didn’t you just take a step back?” DiSabito demonstrated to the court at one point, returning to emphasize the question during his final argument.
Grismore didn’t have strong answers for all of DiSabito’s questions, but then, there are protections in place meant to safeguard law enforcement from such close scrutiny. Kaplan labeled DiSabito’s approach as “Monday-morning quarterbacking,” and the defense’s use-of-force expert Thomas Aveni kept rolling out the case record, Graham v Connor, as a reminder that the police’s use of force – an authority granted by the state in the first place – is typically misunderstood by the general public.
DiSabito later re-labed his approach as “Monday-morning rationalization.”
One of the prosecution’s most effective arguments, however, was a simple side-by-side. During Burrows’ arrest, Burrows also kicked the front of a police cruiser, which resulted in an unlawful mischief charge for him.
The clip – played beside Grismore’s kick – effectively showed that the two actions had much of the same timing and supposed force. DiSabito asked Aveni why the two actions are different? Why was one a kick, and the other a foot-push? Aveni named “intent” as the differentiator.
The prosecution also revealed more information about the circumstances of Burrows as victim. He ended up at the police station after the two deputies on duty responded to Burrows’ mother requesting their help to remove him from her house.
After arriving on scene, it took three deputies to tackle and put handcuffs on Burrows after failing to convince him to leave. During the entanglement, Burrows tried to kick Major, as well as spat on him.
Days later, Burrows could barely recall what happened. He learned that he had been kicked after reading the subsequent media coverage.
But Burrows was not the one on trial, DiSabito reminded the jury. He later slammed Grismore at one point for categorizing Burrows as “being a terrible person” during their encounter.
“We now have a member of the public who’s afraid to call the police,” he said in reference.
To wrap up his arguments at the end of the three-day process, DiSabito leaned on a Judy (AKA Judge Judy) Sheindlin adage to poke a hole in the defense. After so many retellings of the story, he contended that Grismore had always lied about what happened that day.
“If you tell the truth, you don’t have to have a good memory,” he said.
Kaplan’s wider approach, however, seems to have made an impact. While DiSabito focused on Aug. 7, Kaplan asked the jury to take a look around the room. In the small Grand Isle courtroom, at 6 p.m., after three days of legal maneuverings, half the seats were taken up by Grismore’s family members and supporters. The other half were prosecutors and reporters.
“‘It is not the critic who counts; not the man who points out how the strong man stumbles, or where the doer of deeds could have done them better. The credit belongs to the man who is actually in the arena,’” Kaplan countered, using Teddy Roosevelt’s quote to make his point. “We are here with the man in the arena.”
Burrows had also attended the trial Wednesday, but he had left long before the verdict was delivered.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here