Franklin County Sheriff John Grismore gets law enforcement certification revoked; Vermont Criminal Justice Council makes decision after use-of-force hearing

Posted

PITTSFORD – The Vermont Criminal Justice Council voted to permanently revoke Franklin County Sheriff John Grismore’s law enforcement certification Wednesday following the completion of his use-of-force case hearing.

The group came to the ruling after a second day of public testimony and almost 10 hours of legal wrangling examining every angle of an Aug. 7, 2022 incident when then-Capt. Grismore kicked, or foot-pushed, a man in custody.

Since that time, Grismore has been working to uphold public trust in the Franklin County’s Sheriff’s Office. The Vermont Criminal Justice Council’s ruling, however, will make it much more difficult, especially as Grismore deals with a simple assault charge as well as an investigation into the office’s finances, pushed by a House Special Committee on Impeachment inquiry.

More hearing, more context

The case hearings completed by the Vermont Criminal Justice Council on Wednesday primarily focused on whether Grismore’s use of force during the Aug. 7 incident aligned with state policy. Ranging over two days, the hearings themselves featured testimony from the three deputies in the room when it happened – Grismore, Karry Andileigh and Christopher Major – as well as two use-of-force experts largely representing different viewpoints on Grismore’s actions.

The decision against Grismore, however, ended up hinging largely around the potential danger posed by the man in shackles, Jeremy Burrows.

Grismore’s defense, pushed forward by his representing attorney, Robert Kaplan, emphasized the physical threat posed by the man in relation to the rest of the deputies responding that day, while VCJC attorney Kim McManus focused on the egregious-ness of the act itself when the two other deputies seemingly had control of the suspect.

“Was it reasonable to think force was necessary to place Mr. Burrows into a seated position?” McManus said in her closing argument. “That not one, but two kicks were the proportional response to Mr. Burrows behavior? Or was Sheriff Grismore being unreasonable?”

The majority of Wednesday’s testimony given by expert use-of-force witness Tom Aveni, however, demanded that context be included as part of the deliberations.

“The past knowledge (of the previous hours) is contemporaneous,” Aveni said. “It’s not far removed from what happened in the booking area.”

According to Grismore’s testimony given on Nov. 14, both Andileigh and Major had been dispatched Aug. 7 to an area near Machia Road that was known for troublemakers before Burrows was brought into the station.

Grismore said he had been concerned about the call. He had come in that day to do paperwork. Technically, he was on duty, and was functioning as a supervising senior officer to the deputies while at the office.

Meanwhile, Andileigh and Major were arriving on scene. 

As for the reason for the call, Burrow’s mother wanted him out of the house. He was very likely intoxicated, had no shirt on, and he wouldn’t leave. She called the cops.

During Wednesday’s hearing, Grismore’s attorney, Robert Kaplan, showed a clip (twice) from the arrest, taken from Andileigh’s body camera. The footage shows Burrows standing and sitting in his mom’s kitchen, clearly agitated and drunkenly belligerent. Just offscreen, Major can be seen standing, his hands up palms displayed telling Burrows to stand back.

Another deputy stands at the front doorway of the living room about 50 feet away (He had been called in as backup). Two other voices, one most likely mom, can be heard somewhere off frame.

Burrows, however, is Andileigh’s primary concern. As Burrows switches to being a victim, to maybe being sincere, then to threatening Major, the exchange between Andileigh and Burrows would be defined by state policy as a “tense and rapidly evolving circumstance.”

A moment later, Burrows starts moving toward Major, throws a few wide swings, and the three deputies rush to take him to the ground. During the commotion, viewers can see Andileigh’s hands as she cuffs him. The other two deputies keep him flat. Next, the group has to move Burrows and wrestle him up to a standing position. 

It’s hard to tell exactly from the video, but Burrows' leg gets stuck in the limited ground space, as he’s a few feet from a kitchen table, so three deputies have to flip him before he can get to his feet. At which point, he tries to kick another officer.

The rest of the video shows the walk to the cop car, with Burrows cursing most of the way there and kicking a front bumper for good measure. 

Video footage from the hearing also showed the walk from the cop car, through the garage, to the standard white halls of the sheriff’s office. Burrows, still in cuffs, can be heard yelling the whole time. 

“The cuffs were an inhibitor,” Aveni said. “But they didn't eliminate the threat of physical menace.”

The day’s testimony

Aveni, as Kaplan’s primary witness, described himself as the “the trainer of (use-of-force) trainers.” He’s done a lot of research around use of the force and the psychology behind the moments it happens – a four page curriculum vitae was submitted as evidence.

He also gives expert testimony in a lot of use-of-force hearings. In his own words to Kaplan: “It’s primarily all I do, sir.”

On Wednesday, he talked for close to three hours about use-of-force and its continuum, but Kaplan pushed him to emphasize two big points. First, according to case law, you can’t pull a woulda-shoulda when examining use-of-force cases. Kaplan used the phrase “Monday morning quarterback,” and his closing argument started with a football reference to drive it home.

Second, you have to consider the whole picture of the day to understand why Grismore had reacted as he had.

Grismore’s story has taken on a lot of complications over the last year and a half, but most people are generally acquainted with the short video showing him kicking, or foot-pushing, Burrows.

Richard Cowperthwait, a Northwest Access Television interviewer, labeled it the “kick heard around the world,” and for a second there, it had been. For roughly six months post-Aug. 7, that video blew up Grismore’s life, going viral and appearing on a few national news outlets.

Since that time, Grismore won the sheriff’s race, and he’s been actively trying to grow and upgrade the Franklin County Sheriff’s Office by raising pay rates and looking for new contracts. His name has popped up in a few positive stories, and he’s tried to get his own story out there when he can to help diminish his tarnished public image.

But this kick hasn’t gone away. Retaining lawyers for both a simple assault charge – brought forward by Grand Isle State’s Attorney Douglas DiSibato – and this recently-closed use-of-force hearing are expensive endeavors. 

The House Committee has also employed a legal firm specializing in financial investigations to look into the books of the Franklin County Sheriff’s Office. Committee member state Rep. Mike McCarthy (D-St. Albans City) said it took longer than expected to acquire the documents from the office, and Downs Rachlin Martin had issued subpoenas for the information. As a result, the sheriff’s office needed to retain its own counsel to help collect what was needed. 

The House committee has their next meeting planned for Dec. 11 to get an update.

Throughout all the hang-ups, Grismore has looked for a chance to prove his actions were correct. This hearing was one of his bigger windows.

Footpushes and kicks

With its ruling Wednesday, the 16 voting members of the VCJC made it clear they had considered that Grismore had crossed the line with his actions. 

“Grismore failed to comply with the use of force policy by not attempting to deescalate the situation prior to his use of force, or even allowing the other officers to continue to do with their work to support them in their efforts to try and resolve this matter without the need for additional force,” McManus said in her closing argument.

McManus also highlighted the difference between an “imminent threat” and an “immediate threat” during her cross-examinations of Aveni, and she pointed to Vermont’s specific state policy to buffer the argument. Basically, when using less lethal force, officers must consider whether a use-of-force action is required to respond to an “immediate” threat, instead of an “imminent” one.

The legal differentiation helps determine when exactly an officer should respond to potential danger. As the one with the most patrol experience, Grismore said that he had anticipated danger earlier than the other deputies in the room after hearing Burrows start to gather saliva for a spit. He also knew Major got spit on earlier in the day.

By entering the scene, he argued he removed that “imminent threat” by pushing Burrows back into the bench.

“It wasn’t a kick, from a swiveling knee or a swiveling hip,” Aveni said. “It was literally a foot push. ….The first push we saw was relatively mild, it only had a transitory effect. The second one was a little more emphatic.”

As shown in the widely-seen video from the incident, Grismore then walked off screen to grab a spit hood, and after the other two deputies add another shackle to stop Burrows from moving forward, he essentially stops causing issues for those at the station.

Kaplan pointed to the end result as proof that Grismore entering the picture was what gained compliance from Burrows many hours after law enforcement first approached the man. McManus, however, leaned into the idea to make a bigger point about where Vermont’s headed.

“The end justifying the means is precisely the thinking that Vermont has moved away from in its use of force policy. It matters in Vermont how an officer gains compliance. That is important. How much force is used and whether that force is proportional to their behavior that you're seeing in front of you. That matters,” McManus said.

After over a year of back-and-forths, following publication of hundreds of news stories, after many interviews, arguments and testimonials and two days of legal presentations, the Vermont Criminal Justice Council made its determination. It was a kick.

“This was not a slow gentle push on the bench. That had force. This made Mr. Burrows' feet pop out from under him,” McManus said.

Future of policing?

Revocation of Grismore’s Level 2 law enforcement license is expected to go into effect two weeks from now. After that, he’ll be able to continue to function as sheriff in a purely administrative capacity, but he can’t do normal police work. 

In his closing argument, Kaplan warned about the chilling effect that the council’s determination will have on policing in Vermont. Recruiting new officers is already difficult enough in the state, and local police departments are seeing major increases in the costs of policing services due, in part, to the need of increasing salary in order to retain officers.

Ruling against Grismore, Kaplan said in his closing argument, will make people even more hesitant from joining, and potentially drive out those already working in law enforcement and making it more dangerous for everyone else.

“The police were called because the family wanted (Burrows) out of their house,” Kaplan said. “That's the nature of police work. Police show up to take care of the problems that citizens can't or don't want to deal with. “

Hours after the determination, the St. Albans Joint Police Board voted on the final budget for the proposed expanded St. Albans Police Department. If approved by both town and city residents this upcoming Town Meeting Day, the final cost for its first year will be $4.8 million.

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here