ST. ALBANS CITY – The City of St. Albans’ final TIF change is ready for a vote on Town Meeting Day.
The city’s administration presented information on its plans to develop additional housing behind the Bellevue building this past September, and city voters will have a chance to weigh in on the plans March 5, Town Meeting Day.
A “yes” vote on Article 3 would jumpstart plans to construct two apartment buildings – or roughly 90 units of workforce housing – arranged on the block southwest of city hall, add $11.4 million in debt to the city’s TIF plans, pay for brownfield remediation at 45 Kingman St. and cover engineering costs for the Federal Street upgrade.
The city’s housing plan also includes a partial teardown of the Bellevue building. It would keep the historical front facing Main Street, while reconstructing its back half into apartments.
Those looking for more in depth information on the projects are encouraged to attend a public information session on Monday, Feb. 26. The meeting’s agenda includes an extensive overview of the city’s tax increment financing redevelopment bonds, as well as more information on the city budget.
For now, here’s a quick refresher.
The actual ballot language voters will consider on Town Meeting Day is this:
Article 3: TIF Redevelopment Bonds
Shall the City of St. Albans issue general obligation bonds or notes in an amount not to exceed $11.4 million for the purpose of financing Tax Increment Financing District public improvements, namely land acquisition, brownfield remediations, utility improvements, parking construction, site work, roadway construction, streetscaping, professional services, and related costs, and for the payment there of pledge the credit of the City, in particular the revenues generated from the Tax Increment Financing District?
It’s quite a paragraph. Let’s break it down.
“Shall the City of St. Albans issue general obligation bonds or notes in an amount not to exceed $11.4 million for the purpose of financing Tax Increment Financing District public improvements ...”
In this first part of Article 3, the city is asking voters if they will let it borrow more money – $11.4 million – using a special state program called Tax Increment Financing, commonly called TIF.
TIF has been used by the city as a funding mechanism for more than a decade, and the city’s administration – led by City Manager Dominic Cloud – has often identified the financial tool as a major factor behind the city’s redevelopment efforts. City Council President Chad Spooner said it outright during his last city council meeting after 15 years as Ward 6’s alderperson.
“St. Albans would not be where we are today without TIF,” he said.
The actual function of TIF borrows money against the bet that tax revenues will grow due to redevelopment. Funds are typically used to buy or improve properties – including lands tainted by former industrial uses – and bring them up to a more acceptable market rate. The city has used its funds to flip properties, pay for major building upgrades, build the city’s parking garage, overhaul entire blocks and fund major street infrastructure projects.
In the most basic terms, it’s the funding bucket that the City of St. Albans has utilized to change its downtown since 2012. By relying on the TIF, the city estimates it has completed $21 million worth of public improvements and generated $70 million in new taxable values.
Not everyone in the state, however, has loved TIF as a state program.
First, not every municipality in the state has access to using TIF. Because smaller rural municipalities tend to lack the administrative resources necessary for more complex financing tools, state officials have only approved 14 TIF districts across the state, with three more slots open.
Over time, the differentiation has helped drive an imbalance in the state around redevelopment efforts. Essentially, those successful areas – like St. Albans City – have been able to drive up property prices by using borrowed funds for remediation.
Meanwhile, neighboring rural municipalities have seen some bleedover from urban problems. Crime – primarily dangerous drugs and property theft – tops the list of causes for concern. This Town Meeting Day, roughly 40% of Franklin County will be making a decision on whether to increase police funding.
Critics of TIFs have also pointed out the impact on the state’s education fund.
Since TIF districts allow cities to dip into education funding buckets to pay for a percentage of redevelopment costs, taxpayers outside of those areas – in theory – must share a larger cost around having more students.
The State of Vermont’s Joint Fiscal Office estimates that the existence of TIF districts in the state have cost the education fund $5.5 to $7.5 million annually.
City residents also feel an impact on taxes, although it's more indirect. The state’s common level of appraisal – a number released to each municipality annually which changes in relation to property sale prices – is supposed to help offset rapid changes in property valuation, and this year, the city’s shrinking CLA, caused by two years of rapid increases in housing prices, has put the screws to taxpayers by giving them a higher education tax rate.
Maple Run Unified School District Superintendent Bill Kimball highlighted the City of St. Albans’ low CLA during a presentation made to City Council this past Monday. Using graphs to highlight how the school board has worked to keep school budgets low, Kimball showed councilors how the CLA is one of the reasons why city residents will feel the crunch of higher education tax rates this year.
“The state has helped us invest a lot of money here,” State Rep. Michael McCarthy explained in relation to the TIF. “There’s a give and a take here as well, and this is part of the consequence of having this statewide mechanism and being able to leverage it.”
“But long term, the state is going to benefit significantly,” Mayor Tim Smith added.
“And we all benefit significantly from having a much nicer community to live in,” McCarthy replied.
The city is currently undertaking efforts to change its CLA. The process requires a citywide re-assessment, and an outside firm has been hired to complete the work.
The end result, however, will most likely be a mixed bag for residents. Some will see their annual taxes go down, but not all will.
Finally, TIF critics have expressed worries about the city’s growing financial debt. Cloud downplayed the concerns Monday, pointing out that state officials gave the city the go-ahead necessary for the city to expand the TIF’s debt ceiling, which would be $33 million, if approved by voters.
“In a nutshell, this is our last chance to use TIF,” Cloud said. “It is hands down the most powerful economic development tool in the state. Look around St. Albans. You can see what it’s done for our city and I’m asking the voters to allow us to do that one last time and complete projects that quite simply can’t be completed without it. That’s what we have on the ballot.”
Here’s the second part of the question.
“… namely land acquisition, brownfield remediations, utility improvements, parking construction, site work, roadway construction, streetscaping, professional services, and related costs, and for the payment there of pledge the credit of the City, in particular the revenues generated from the Tax Increment Financing District?”
This part of the question effectively answers what the city plans to do with the $11.4 million.
Essentially, the TIF would finance three projects. A total of $10 million will be set aside for the two apartment buildings. The city purchased the Welden Theater as part of a package deal last year, and the abutting properties have been held in order for the city to pursue a public-private partnership with a developer to create two new apartment buildings, primarily for middle class working people.
The Welden Theater itself, however, will remain standing, and plans are being hatched to update the building.
As for who would live in the proposed apartments, Cloud estimated that income levels for residents will be a little bit higher and a little bit lower than the median household income for the area, which is $74,2000 for a two-person household.
The rest of the $11.4 million requested would cover aspects of two other redevelopment projects. The smaller request for $200,000, for example, would help fund the brownfield remediation efforts at 45 Kingman Street. The old courthouse building was sold to developer Jim Cameron two years ago, and his crew has been retrofitting the building to hold a first-floor commercial space and upper story apartments.
The brownfield remediation piece paid by the city included replacing the first few feet of topsoil in the building’s yard, due to the existence of toxic pollutants.
The final remaining $1.2 million will help cover engineering and design costs related to the Federal Street project. The city received $7.7 million in federal grant dollars to fulfill its vision of upgrading the street last summer, and the city’s administration has been working with federal officials to make it happen over the last year. The $1.2 million would help complete the planning process.
The city’s planning director, Chip Sawyer, said Monday that construction for Federal Street will most likely be a few years away, either 2025 or 2026.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here