NMC, RN union might need GMCB's help

Posted

Less than a year ago, the registered nurses at Northwestern Medical Center voted to form a union, which initiated the lengthy process of negotiating a contract to satisfy the RNs and still remain within NMC’s budget. 

In an Op-ed in last week’s Messenger, Interim NMC CEO Jonathan Billings explained that the process is slow-going and that both sides had reached a “tentative agreement on about one third of the approximate fifty articles and have made good progress on the others…”

Elsewhere on this page [see below], members of the union felt the need to articulate their side of the negotiations, essentially saying their needs still have yet to be addressed, those needs being higher wages, better staffing ratios, and safer environments, among others. They also question NMC’s decision to spend $7 million on “travelers”, contending that “We need local nurses taking care of our community.”

If the negotiations were between NMC and its RNs, perhaps things would move faster and a bit more smoothly. But there is a third party not at the table, and that’s the Green Mountain Care Board, Vermont’s healthcare regulator, the folks who decide what the hospital can and cannot spend. In a Vermont Public story this week, the five-member board announced it wanted the state’s hospitals to cut what they charge private insurers by one percent. 

Healthcare is a personal service. As such, the biggest line item on a hospital’s budget is labor. The American Hospital Association reports that labor constitutes roughly 60 percent of a hospital’s annual costs. Of that 60 percent, about half goes to RNs, or about 30 percent of the total.

In other words, for NMC to remain within the regulator’s proposed budget, one of two things would need to happen: the hospital would need to cut its budget elsewhere - and substantially, or it would need a reprieve from the Green Mountain Care Board.

That’s the fiscal side of the argument. The money is tight. The GMCB wants all hospitals to cut costs so that healthcare premiums for Vermonters are lowered. [Currently, our premiums are the nation’s highest.]

But it’s also easy to see the nurses’ side of the argument, much of which is beyond their immediate control. The supply of RNs in Vermont runs at a trickle. We have 400 nursing graduates each year. The demand is for about three times that number. According to Vermont Talent Pipeline, there are six nursing roles in healthcare, and of the six, RNs are the most in-demand group.

Following the rules of supply and demand, the graduates can choose where they would like to work. That makes it difficult for small hospitals like NMC. It also puts them in the position of needing to hire “travelers” just to fill the roster. One way or another, Vermont has to figure out a way to create systems that produce more RNs.

The cost of healthcare continues to be one of Vermont’s top challenges, along with housing and the cost of education. And it’s not an issue of hospitals like NMC hoarding mounds of cash. Or its CEO drawing a multi-million dollar pay package. NMC has been losing money for years.

NMC knows its RNs are a key pillar to its operational success. And the hospital’s RNs know the value of NMC to the community. The hope is that they are able to come to an agreement, but both sides may need the GMCB to give the hospital some additional breathing room. 

By Emerson Lynn

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here