Vermont needs the steadiness of Phil Scott as governor

Posted

Gov. Phil Scott has always had his struggles with the right wing of the Republican Party. The moderates of both the Democratic and Republican parties have fueled his popularity, content with his frugality and reasonableness. That support may still buy Mr. Scott an historic sixth term. If so, the margin will be thinner than he’s used to. His opponent, Democrat/Progressive Amanda Janoo, is within the margin of error in this week’s poll. Not only is Mr. Scott battling voter fatigue, but he’s also weighted down by a Republican Party led by a deeply unpopular president pushing flawed policies that challenge us nationally and internationally. In deep-blue Vermont, it doesn’t take much of a voter shift to the left for Mr. Scott to find himself in the closest race of his five-term tenure.

As flawed as President Trump’s policies are, Vermont has its own problems, and we need to find our own answers. Of the two candidates, Mr. Scott has the necessary experience and is far and away the best choice to navigate Vermont for the next two years. He is a political moderate and long on experience. Ms. Janoo is to the left of Sen. Bernie Sanders and is pushing proposals that could profoundly affect Vermont’s future, proposals that have not been examined for effectiveness or affordability.

Ms. Janoo, for example, was quoted on WPTZ as saying she would limit the number of residents and businesses moving to Vermont to address our housing costs. It’s part of her “wellbeing” economy and her “post-growth” plan. She wants to build our economy on what already exists.

Vermont is currently losing people and businesses. How do we stay viable if we continue to lose what we have? How would she decide who is worthy of moving to Vermont? Has any state set up such a policy? Doesn’t that smack of discrimination? What state has a governor who sets standards as to who is welcome and who isn’t? Vermont needs workers in all business sectors. Which does Ms. Janoo think is not welcome? And if she makes it clear which people and which businesses are not welcome, what sort of message does that send to people already here who are among the “unwanted?” That’s just nuts.

Ms. Janoo goes a step further and describes our tourist economy in Vermont as “extractive,” which means she thinks we lose more than we gain. Really. We attract about 16 million visitors each year, and they spend over $4 billion in our businesses. That generates over $300 million in tax revenue. How is that a negative? How does she explain her opposition to tourism to the 30,000 Vermonters whose jobs depend on it? Again, that’s nuts.

Ms. Janoo proposes establishing a universal health care program for primary and preventive care. It would offer free primary and preventive health care for every Vermonter. No copays, no deductibles. Free. She would pay for it by levying a two-percent tax on people with incomes of $250,000 and an eight-percent tax on those with incomes above $500,000. The new taxes would make our marginal tax rate the highest in the nation.  She contends it would generate over $320 million, but the amount hasn’t been verified. And paying for the state’s universal primary care needs would cost roughly $600 million. Where does the extra $300 million come from? She doesn’t say. Would the tax be indexed for inflation? She doesn’t say.  What happens if high-income Vermonters decide the ask is too much and they leave? She doesn’t say. If primary care becomes free and demand increases, which is likely, we will need to expand the number of providers, which increases costs. How are these challenges addressed? She doesn’t say. She offers her proposal as a necessary beginning of a single-payer system. Really? At what cost? She doesn’t say.

Ms. Janoo has proposed dealing with the state’s housing crisis by increasing taxes on certain types of property, including second homes, commercial vacation rentals, vacant investment properties, and properties owned by corporations. She was quoted recently as saying we need to stop treating “housing as an investment rather than as a home.”

We have no idea what that means. Three-quarters of Vermonters own their own home, and that home represents about half their net worth. Of course it’s an investment. How else do you treat it? Ms. Janoo also proposes slapping a tax on luxury second homes and properties owned by corporations. But she says there is not enough information to say what sort of tax she would levy. And the state housing authorities say the practice of corporations buying large numbers of housing in Vermont doesn’t exist. Yet, despite this, Ms. Janoo says she wants to extract about a billion dollars from taxes on these homes. How? She doesn’t say.

On the issue of energy, Ms. Janoo opposes nuclear power, saying it is connected to the AI industry and the building of data farms. Mr. Scott disagrees, wisely, understanding the vast potential of small-scale nuclear power, perhaps at the Vermont Yankee site in Vernon. To slam the door on such potential is small-scale thinking, environmentally and financially.

Ms. Janoo is long on theoretical advice and woefully short of the experience Vermont needs in its next governor. Her only elected office experience? Justice of the Peace in Burlington. Her political philosophy? To the party’s far left. Her answer to affordability? Raise taxes.

Mr. Scott is far and away the better choice. As a political moderate, he’s in a tough position between the MAGA right and the far-left progressives. But it’s still the middle position where most of the work is accomplished. It’s the position from which our divided ways can be joined in a common purpose.

By Emerson Lynn

 

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here