Letter to the Editor: In union negotiations, proposals speak louder than words

Posted

This letter is from RNs Sarah Rumsby, Christine Juaire and Rose Arnett. 

In a recent Letter to the Editor, Interim CEO Jonathan Billings highlighted the values that Northwestern Medical Center shares with our RN union, Northwestern Healthcare United. He was responding to a petition signed by nearly 1600 community members urging management to agree to a first contract for nurses that includes safe staffing ratios, a sustainable on-call system, competitive starting wage, and policies to protect and provide care for nurses who experience workplace violence.

We, and many of our colleagues, appreciate Jonathan’s transparency and long service to our hospital. However, it’s important our community understands the disconnect between what NMC management is saying to the public and what they are proposing at the bargaining table.

For instance, NMC is saying they agree with the need for safe staffing and use “evidence-based staffing models,” but management has rejected all staffing ratio language in our contract, even non-binding guidelines. They rejected the creation of a hospital-wide staffing committee, and it took several rounds of bargaining to get them to agree to a basic form that would track instances of low staffing. This resistance runs contrary to NMC's stated commitment to safe staffing. When nurses, especially new nurses, are tasked with too many patients, the quality of care suffers — there’s no way around it. We’ve seen our coworkers cry after shifts from sheer exhaustion and overwhelm. We are bargaining simply to create a shared, articulated goal for staffing ratios and NMC has refused.

A similar story has unfolded regarding competitive wages. NMC says they want to reduce their reliance on travelers and raise starting wages. Their initial proposal for RN starting wages was $5-10 dollars lower than other hospitals around the state – not just UVM Medical Center – and gave 0% cost of living increases across the board for 3 years. Our new nurses are leaving for nearby correctional facilities and clinics because they cannot afford to stay at NMC. Meanwhile our budget for travelers has grown every year. NMC has allocated over 7 million for travelers in fiscal year 2026. This dependence is fiscally damaging for our hospital, and impacts the quality of patient care. We need local nurses taking care of our neighbors.

Bargaining a contract is an enormous investment of time and energy. For our union team it’s entirely unpaid. We want, more than anyone, to reach a fair contract and invest that energy back in our jobs, families and community. But we love this hospital too much

to agree to, for example, an on-call system that would require our OR nurses to work for 16 consecutive hours, or to come in at 6am after a middle of the night emergency surgery — as management’s current proposal would allow. These are unsafe policies, and we can not accept them.

We’re ready for a new chapter at NMC. We want to believe that management shares our values. The challenges facing healthcare in Vermont are large and we want to confront them together. We cannot move forward while management refuses to schedule additional bargaining sessions, or agree even to the most standard union contract language. Our community deserves a hospital that is focused on quality care. NMC needs to put their values into action, and present proposals which will recruit, retain and protect local nurses.

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here