Let’s answer basic questions before the 2028 race

Posted

When Republican Phil Scott won the Nov. 3 gubernatorial election, it came with the lament that Democrats would return to the Legislature in January with a veto-proof majority. That took a bit of the polish off Mr. Scott’s victory, with the expectation that we would see a return of a do-nothing Legislature.

If that happens, both sides misread what Vermonters want, which is to get things done. Voters have no real love of either party, as all polls show. What they want is for life to be more affordable.

 Which leads to the past gubernatorial election and how the Democrats will comport themselves between now and the 2028 election. The question on everyone’s lips is whether Democrat/Progressive Amanda Janoo will re-up her desire to be governor.

She’s earned it. She came from nowhere to within about seven points of unseating Mr. Scott. She’s smart. She’s articulate. And she’s kind. She left the playground with no ill feelings on either side. No small feat. 

Her challenge will be the lack of a bully pulpit from now until then. It will be difficult for her to remain in the public’s view. Meanwhile, an expected contender like State Treasurer Mike Pieciak is not only interested in the governor’s chair, but has statewide name recognition and a job that keeps him in front of Vermonters on a daily basis. He’s also smart. 

It would surprise no one if other contenders - like Ally Richards - will take another shot at the job. Since it’s almost a dead certainty that Mr. Scott won’t run for a seventh term, people are already treating the 2028 gubernatorial election as an expected free-for-all. 

But here’s where things become interesting. Nationally, the Democrats co-opted the “affordability” mantra from the Republicans and have made it their own. The question is whether the Dems will follow through. In Vermont, Ms. Janoo tried to do the same, but to less effect. Mr. Scott, after all, coined the term and has based his entire six terms on its importance.

With Mr. Scott out of the picture in 2028, candidates on both sides of the aisle will battle for its constituents. There is every reason to believe Congressional Democrats will make the same play, perhaps offering an assist to Vermont’s Democrats in terms of what works, what’s popular, and what meets the public’s needs. 

Maybe. But one of the reasons Ms. Janoo fell short was that she didn’t have answers to what her proposals would cost. Ms. Richards made this clear in the primary when she called Ms. Janoo’s proposals “magical” thinking. Mr. Scott made the same claim, but there was no follow-up. There was no investigation as to what would work and what wouldn’t, and at what cost.

That was also frustrating to voters. How do you support someone if you have no idea whether the claims are anywhere close to being accurate?

Here’s a thought: We have at least a year to prepare for the 2028 race; why not employ the Legislature’s Joint Fiscal Office to do the legwork necessary to answer the questions we know are coming. For example, Ms. Janoo and the Dems are pushing for a universal primary and preventive health care plan. It was proposed to fund it by raising taxes on high-income Vermonters. So, would it work? And what cost? Let’s find out. It was proposed that raising taxes on second-home owners would help finance essential home construction needs. So how many homes, at what cost, and at what increased tax rate? Ms. Janoo opposed closing rural schools and instead proposed turning them into wraparound locations for social, health, and family services. Would that work? Have the Joint Fiscal Committee do the math. 

The point is that we have the resources to do the work necessary to attach a price to a proposal. What we need to avoid is another election where candidates can promise what they can’t deliver. That’s not the progress voters are looking for.

By Emerson Lynn

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here