FRANKLIN COUNTY — With age comes breakdowns.
Every complex system stops working as intended over time — whether it be the human body or public infrastructure.
It’s kind of like getting high cholesterol. Village Manager Bill Sheets said he uses the metaphor regularly when talking about old tuberculated underground pipes.
“It's the inside of the pipe just literally becoming so restrictive, the flow of water just can't happen,” he said.
Without a fix, both examples make it harder for pumps to move material resources around the larger body. It’s just when there’s a public utility involved, there’s about a few hundred more ratepayers making the decisions about the fix.
And are they willing to cover the costs to prevent the proverbial heart attack?
Village of Swanton trustees approved rate increases on all three of its utilities this past month, but they’re still unsure exactly what’s coming down the line for their electric rates. For years, they’ve been able to provide electricity at the cheapest rate in Vermont.
That era will likely end soon. Right now, the village administration is spending tens of thousands of dollars each month to buy power to serve its customers while tackling a major revenue problem.
The big question plaguing their future trendlines is figuring out how soon can the Orman E. Croft Power Dam be ready to reach its full operational-capacity again to tamp down on those costs.
“It’s what keeps me up at night,” Sheets said. “How are we going to fix that? How are we going to find the sweet spot in a cost-benefit analysis, which pencils out mathematically, where we can say to the public: Here's why this makes the most sense. And it all depends on what happens with (the Federal Energy Regulation Commission) and the State of Vermont.”
Since 2018, the village had been relying on a big balloon-like device to do most of its heavy lifting at the dam. Usually referred to as an air bladder, the black rubber mechanism kept water levels high when it inflated, essentially giving dam operators expanded room to “pond” and/or release water when necessary to keep turbines spinning at their peak electricity-generating capacities.
The 47-ton balloon, however, ended up popping this past August. Trustees and the village administration have been spinning since to find a solution to the incident, especially after maintenance workers had just made repairs on the device.
“It has nothing to do with maintenance. It has nothing to do with any of that,” Sheets clarified. “This product failed six years out of the warranty.”
Either way, the village now has to deal with the repercussions. As for the latest news, trustees and the administration brought in consultant Celeste Fay, of engineering firm Velergy, earlier this year to determine some next steps. A potential interim solution, Fay explained in April, is to install a system of clapboards on top of the dam to raise the water a few extra feet in order to help deal with the debris clogging up the village’s water intake. The quickgap solution still needs federal approval.
If the village can do that, then the dam should have an easier time generating electricity at about 80% of its peak pre-breakdown, essentially plugging the revenue hole the bladder pop created.
The long-term solution, however, is still being determined, Sheets said.
“We have to live with the conditions that we have while we slowly and methodically determine what the best long-term solution is. It's two to three years away,” he said. “You do not engineer and navigate these massive projects quickly, and then we still have no idea, because it hasn't been engineered. What then we'll do is a massive cost benefit analysis.”
In the meantime, the lack of an air bladder is causing additional wear-and-tear on the infrastructure. Sheets showed a video dam operators had taken as an example.
The brief clip depicted a plume of liquid bursting out of the grate just outside the main dam facility, where water had backwashed in the penstock and slapped up against the incoming stream.
“You can see, it’s ‘Old Faithful’” Sheets said, referencing the famous Yellowstone geyser. “So that’s like a water hammer effect. That’s bad.”
Thanks to the phenomenon, the extra wear-and-tear from the energy at play has made the village’s five turbines — many of them decades old — more likely to break down. Just like one health problem can cause cascading complications, Swanton’s air bladder failure continues to impact overall operations, Sheets said.
Ultimately, the Vermont Public Power Supply Authority is in charge of determining electricity rates for municipal utilities, which is accomplished by checking known financial measurables to determine how much the nonprofit will need to cover its expenses. Until the air bladder problem has an answer, it leaves a huge question mark regarding the electric utility’s future revenues, as well as its future rates.
As for the increases behind water and wastewater fees, trustees recently approved a 20% jump in sewer and a 37% jump in water. Sheets said the village administration sets rates to cover capital and maintenance costs.
On the wastewater side, the village is on the cusp of wrapping up a large upgrade at its wastewater treatment facility. Voters approved the project roughly two years ago, and the bond payments are now coming due.
As for water costs, a similar situation is playing out around Swanton’s latest water line project, which installed a redundant line under the Missisquoi River to answer some of the state’s concerns around emergency preparedness. Sheets estimated the financial impact to ratepayers is just over a quarter, or 28 cents more per day, for water.
“In terms of our scope, all of them are impactful, and nobody likes raising rates.” Sheets said. “The percentages are perhaps scarier than the monetary amount.”
About half of Franklin County’s 14 towns make do without any municipally-owned utilities, leaving many residents to lean on privately-owned septic systems and/or private wells to provide water and wastewater to their rural homes.
The State of Vermont, however, has recognized the underlying issue. An overreliance on private systems — instead of public utilities — hampers development due to associated costs. In contrast, pooling funds and efforts spreads out those costs across a wider financial base, which makes them more affordable, in theory.
But then again, those who already have private systems won’t see any benefits from the public work.
It’s why public utilities can sometimes be “political” in Vermont, Lynette Claudon, the chief engineer who serves on Vermont’s Village Wastewater Initiative Committee, said.
Her group has helped Vermont’s most rural areas start their journey into the public utility arena, and they’ve played a heavy part providing information to both Highgate and Montgomery, as town officials move through the necessary permitting around their wastewater projects.
As for the latest, in Montgomery, town officials and state planners are close to entering the construction phase on its wastewater system to serve its village and center as the project enters its fourth year. And in Highgate, town officials and the selectboard still need to decide how to move forward with the high cost of a proposed water system to serve its village core senior housing project after getting the wastewater planning process started back in 2019.
In both of those cases, town leaders and residents started examining a wastewater project after recognizing the need as a foundational element undergirding additional economic development, usually around a downtown or village core area.
Claudon said that’s typical. Vermont requires that municipal leadership move the momentum along and bring community members with them to meet their goals. Sometimes the impetus stems from an initial idea had by a selectboard member, or through the planning process put forward by a local planning commission, but the state is generally wary of telling towns they need a public utility.
If they want one, however, that’s a different story, Claudon said. While wastewater systems can be expensive, the funds to cover wastewater projects are pulled from Vermont’s Clean Water State Revolving Loan Fund. A few options also exist on the federal side, but in Vermont, the large majority come from the state fund.
For FY 2026, $267 million was requested from the fund to cover associated wastewater projects, according to its intended use plan.
The standard process requires that utilities apply for the funds, which are then awarded based on need. Multiple failed septic systems tainting groundwater, for example, can boost a project’s ranking, Claudon said, in order to help cover capital costs associated.
If the funds end up approved, the other major variable which drives a project’s success is usually the people involved, she said.
“It’s cliche to say, but it takes a village,” Claudon said. “It does take a lot of people working in collaboration to make one of the projects happen.”
Most wastewater projects take at least five years before completion. Many stretch up to a decade as each stage of the process requires plenty of expertise. The Village Wastewater Initiative Committee leans on the Northwest Regional Planning Commission to help in Franklin County if a municipal leader lacks the experience needed for large-scale development.
Running a public utility after it’s completed also usually requires additional staff and resources to keep it moving. Surprise costs can be a regular phenomenon.
In Fairfax, for example, the selectboard has been trying to maneuver through difficulties related to its wastewater facility as it deals with high chemical and sludging costs that have ballooned over time.
Even St. Albans City has issues when breakdowns occur with aging infrastructure. The city last updated its own wastewater treatment facility starting in 2018, although recently, ongoing issues around sludge removal and costly repairs related to the city’s centrifuge — the machine that removes water from biosolids — has caused recent issues.
When the machine isn’t working, the city has to pay more to haul its bio-solids to New York for disposal, which has helped push city wastewater fees up at a faster rate than water.
The flat fee for wastewater usage, for example, was close to even with the city’s residential flat fee rate for water back in 2013. Now, wastewater costs about $15 more than water per household, and its usage fees have doubled within the same time period.
But then, the other option is not relying on a utility at all. In Swanton’s case, instead of fixing its hydroelectric dam, the village could choose to sell it.
“We're also putting — we don't have it yet, but — a generic valuation of what the facility is in its current condition and what its value is on the market,” Sheets said. “But that's really, I think it's going to be a non-starter for the trustees.”
Back in April, Fay told trustees how much of an asset the dam has been to Swanton. Thanks to the forward-thinking actions of previous generations, Swanton residents have seen low electric rates on their bills for decades, essentially freeing up funds for other needs.
If they were to sell the power-generating resource, Sheets said the village would lose much of its control around its electricity pricing. This next investment will be a step up on rates, he said, but if they can get the costs under control in the next few years, then over time, they’ll eventually be able to make Swanton electric one of the cheapest in the state again.
Because it’s hard to find anyone in government — local or otherwise — who expects Vermont to become more affordable in the next few years. Right now, many public utility managers have returned to maintenance mode after recognizing people’s economic situations.
On the village’s water front, for example, Sheets said trustees are in the early stages of determining what downtown water lines need the most help after decades of natural decay. Many have clogged up with mineral deposits, according to an April presentation by Aldrich+Elliott, and the village is working closely with water engineers to find out what’s next.
Moments later, at that same meeting, a few residents came with concerns about village water fees. Beth White, the head of Habitat for Aviation, said the nonprofit’s monthly bill had jumped to over $200 per month when they connected into the Village of Swanton’s water line after service was extended out to the Franklin County Airport.
Trustees are considering the request to lower nonprofit rates, Sheets said.
“It's our responsibility to manage and upgrade those lines that are breaking the most often — those problem spots, and that's what we're trying to do,” he said. “And there's not enough money to do all that. Even with these rate increases, we're just trying to maintain what we're delivering now.”
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here