Enosburg trustees reject declaration of inclusion; discuss possible ATV ordinance

Posted

ENOSBURG FALLS – Enosburg Village’s board of trustees decided not to adopt a declaration of inclusion during its July meeting. 

In a 4-1 vote, trustees soundly voted against the declaration, questioning the reason why the village would need to sign the declaration when the village is already “very inclusive.”

“I guess I feel everything is inclusive unless explicitly stated exclusive,” trustees chair Eli Gabuzda said. 

But while most of the board was unified, trustee Heather Moore provided the lone dissent. To her, if the village were to have signed on to the declaration, it would have signaled how inclusive the area is to those who haven’t had the same friendly experience as members of the board and public talk about.  

Trustees had the declaration on their agenda earlier in June, but decided to hold off on any decisions until a vacant seat could be filled by Jason Longway this month. 

In May 2021, Gov. Phil Scott declared the second week of May “Inclusion Week” in Vermont. The proclamation came as towns across the state began adopting Declarations of Inclusion, affirming the state’s commitment to welcoming individuals of all backgrounds, traditions, and abilities.

Since then, 163 towns and cities throughout all 14 counties have signed on in support by adopting a declaration of inclusion, but Enosburg Village and Town have not.

Those in attendance at the meeting were just as mixed as the trustees. 

Some members of the public said they’ve seen other towns rescind their declarations, while others asked how adopting the inclusion statement could be detrimental to the community and if the village is so inclusive then there is nothing wrong with signing on. 

Other towns in Franklin County have similarly had larger conversations about inclusion. Some set up inclusion committees, like in St. Albans City, while others only went only so far as to approve the declaration.

As of May 8, Georgia, St. Albans City, Fairfax, Bakersfield, Richford, Franklin and Swanton have adopted the declaration, according to the organization who tracks the information. 

“I personally don't think we need to sign something the governor wants us [to sign] saying we are inclusive,” resident Brenda Stanley said at the July meeting. “We are inclusive. I’ve never felt excluded from this community for anything. I have some family members that are biracial, that [have] gender issues and they never ever have not felt welcome here.” 

But Moore said the public statement is just showing off the values of the village. It’s for the people who don’t feel comfortable to speak up and hear from governmental officials. 

“I view this as we are just telling our community we value everybody, and as we move forward as a community, we will make adjustments as they come up,” she said. 

For example, Moore said officials have already gone through contracts to make terminology more inclusive, moving away from gendered terminology. She also pointed to the bandstand currently being removed so it can meet Americans with Disabilities Act compliance. 

The bandstand had unintentionally been designed to exclude individuals who can’t walk up stairs, Moore said, so the village is making an effort to be more inclusive. But, public members fought back on the bandstand, saying stairs don’t make it exclusionary.

“If someone wanted to get up there, someone would come help,” an audience member said. 

Still when members of the public asked how signing the declaration would affect anything at all, others responded saying it would show the town was admitting wrongdoing. 

“Because it makes us look like we’ve been excluding,” Stanley said. “That’s my take on it. You’ve excluded all these people so you have to make a statement on it when we haven’t.” 

In the end, however, the majority of the trustees believed that if they approved the declaration it could put the village at fault for major complaints. Gabuzda said if someone in the village has a bad experience, they would be able to come to the village and hold them accountable because of the declaration. 

Trustee David Gervais, however, said the original intent of the inclusion statement was to bring more business into communities. Cities like Burlington and Rutland have adopted the statement, but he asked if any of those communities have seen a boost of economic benefit. 

“He [Gov. Scott] signed this in 2021,” Gervais said. “The way I see it, I think things have gotten a lot worse.” 

Drafting an ordinance

Similarly to the inclusion declaration, All Terrain Vehicle discussions were put on hold until the new trustee came on board this month. The trustees have been considering allowing side-by-sides through village streets after representatives from the Northwest Vermont Wheelers Association made the request at previous meetings. 

The trustees directed the village manager to draft up an ordinance for review by the next meeting before possibly putting the idea out to vote. 

With more of the public in attendance, there was a stronger dissenting voice. 

Raymond Ferland said he was extremely opposed to allowing ATVs in the village. He said Enosburg already has traffic problems on Main Street. Sometimes it’s “more like a drag strip,” he said, so there’s no reason to increase the problem. 

Another problem, for those opposed, was the lack of police. The lack of a police presence in the village has made it difficult to control when ATVs drive through sidewalks and neighborhoods, some of the residents said. 

In earlier meetings, Albert Desrochers, a member of the Northwest Wheelers, said ATV users can bring in a lot of business to the towns who have opened up. Going to get gas, stopping for a bite to eat and going shopping have revitalized downtowns, he said. 

But, resident Sally Tryhorne disputed that sentiment during the July meeting. To her, it’s turned pristine locations into dirty areas. 

“We spend a lot of time in Newport, we have for decades,” she said. “It has gone from a beautiful, peaceful city to a pretty wild place. We sit out there having ice cream and it’s just vroom vroom all these muddy people, muddy cars. It’s not peaceful anymore.” 

The noise, David Tryhorne said, is also a problem. They are the “worst sounding motor” he’s ever heard, he said. 

In the riders’ corner, trustee Leonard Charron vouched for the group. He said the vehicles are expensive to purchase and often owned by people who have property and who have worked all their life. 

“The youngest is like 60-years-old. They’re not hellraisers. They’re out riding trails, come into the village to eat, gas up and maybe go to the hotel,” he said. “They come in groups and they leave because they’re trail riding and can’t get gas or food on the trails.” 

The village has tried to squeeze a buck out of people using canoes and the rail trail. Charron said ATVs could be the next tourism opportunity for Enosburg. 

“I see a lot of four-wheelers with kids on the back,” he said. “Don’t blame the older generation that just wants to enjoy their side-by-sides.” 

Still, the trustees decided it was best to draft up an ordinance that way residents of the village could have a public comment period to refine the proposal and then put it out to the voters in the future.

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here