Why would any parent choose not to have their baby vaccinated for hepatitis B when they know transmission doesn’t just happen mother-to-baby, that it can be transmitted through casual contact, and that about 90 percent of infected babies go on to develop chronic hepatitis B, a lifelong incurable disease?
They wouldn’t.
The proof is in understanding that universal newborn vaccinations have driven childhood hepatitis B infections down from 18,000 cases in 1991 to about 20 today. That meets anyone’s standard of success.
So, what’s the issue?
The issue is that last week, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention’s vaccine advisory committee voted to end the universal birth-dose recommendation. Parents can elect to have it, but it’s not required. They can even wait two months and decide then if they want their child vaccinated. They also don’t need to have all three doses if the first dose meets a certain standard.
As widely reported, there is no scientific evidence that the birth dose is unsafe. There is no evidence that waiting two months offers any advantage, as the panel’s recommendations hint.
So why is this happening? It’s happening because Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. is a vaccine skeptic, and to ensure his doubts are acted upon, he replaced the CDC’s advisory board with like-minded skeptics. The recommended change in the hepatitis B vaccination is the first step.
What’s terrifying about the panel’s recommendation is that it creates distrust where none should exist. It puts people at risk. There is no data to support the panel’s recommendation. The scientific evidence we have depended on is no longer in play.
The best advice?
It came from Vermont’s new state Health Commissioner, Rick Hildebrant, who said, “Do not listen to a politician when it comes to health care decisions, please. These are decisions that belong in an exam room, and they are the people who are the best equipped to give you information about this.”
Amen.
Mr. Hildebrant and his medical brethren in Vermont are incredulous as to the recommendations coming from the CDC, to the point where Vermont has joined a regional coalition made up of eight Northeast states whose purpose is to react to Mr. Kennedy and his department’s directions. In essence, to fight fiction with facts.
That’s a more difficult challenge than it should be. As the old saying goes, a lie gets halfway around the world before the truth has a chance to get its pants on.
Suffice it to say, it won’t work to simply point out the error of Mr. Kennedy’s ways and assume common sense will prevail. The responsible path forward should involve not only the state health department, but our insurers - BCBS and MVP - and our health care community. There should be a statewide campaign to correct what Mr Kennedy has corrupted. And it should be constant.
It’s a bigger issue than one might expect. A large percentage of our health care dollars comes from the federal government. As we’re seeing, the Trump administration is making it clear that states could lose some of their funding if they don’t abide by the administration’s preferred policies.
Isn’t it remarkable that we live in an artificial intelligence era in which we can process vastly more information than ever before, yet we find ourselves hamstrung by leaders who are blinded by ages-old beliefs? Isn’t it astounding that our nation’s health is being guided by someone who hasn’t a clue about the science that has backed decades of trial and error?
You just can’t make this up.
By Emerson Lynn
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here