It was the election no one saw coming and Senate Democrats gathered last Saturday to admit the obvious. It was, in the words of Senate President Pro Tem Phil Baruth, the “worst election” he’d ever experienced.
Mr. Baruth told his fellow Democrats that the message from Vermonters was clear: “Vermonters want the property tax reduced. Period.” He said the Senate would treat the issue as a public “emergency.”
The issue goes far beyond the property tax, but the question remains: How did the Democrats miss the voters’ anger, how could they not have heard their constituents’ concerns about the inability to meet everyday costs? The same could be asked of the presidential race on a national level.
The reason isn’t complicated. They saw what they wanted to see. They listened to those who had their ears. They read from those whose views they sought. It’s a behavior model that knows no political party. It’s a model shaped by our experiences, those with whom we associate and respect, and our cultural preferences. In Vermont’s case, it’s also a natural reflection of a political elite, including the media. Think about it: Going into the election our entire political structure, Gov. Phil Scott notwithstanding, was a list of big-name Democrats and all are on the Democratic Party’s left wing.
So it is easy to understand why Democrats were over-confident. Their entire political model was in play, one that had been their aid and comfort for decades. They missed what they didn’t want to hear.
There is, however, a profound difference between “hearing” the voters’ message and actions that reflect those concerns. It’s mistaken, for example, to confine the voters’ concern about high costs to the property tax. It’s much more than that. Legislators must also deal with health care costs and premiums many Vermonters cannot afford. They need to redo their failed attempt to address the state’s housing needs. They need to ditch legislation to implement the Clean Heat Standards.
It’s also a mistake for Democrats to sit back and wait for Mr. Scott to offer the specificity they would like in dealing with school costs and a funding formula that would reduce property taxes. That’s not only a cop-out, it’s weak leadership. If Democrats want to be welcomed back into the public’s good graces, they will find answers of their own. They are, after all, the party with a majority in both houses.
Republicans also need to be mindful of their new-found strength and the attending responsibility it invites. Contrary to the national scene, Vermont’s political divisions are not of the “identity politics” variety. With Mr. Scott’s moderate image at the forefront, we have a Republican Party much less focused on the cultural issues that are so prevalent nationally. The divide between the state’s Republicans and Democrats is less here than in most other states. Our battles are not zero-sum us/them.
That’s a blessing.
It’s also the perhaps subliminal message from Vermonters to their elected officials: Nothing of importance can be accomplished if there is no shared effort toward a common goal. While Democrats may lament their loss of a veto-proof majority and Republicans thrill to their “historic” win what voters want is for the challenges to be met and to be resolved. Voters are less interested in anointing one party or the other as the victor. The more challenging the problem the more that is so, and right now, figuring out how to make ends meet and to save a little is the concern that overrides all others.
That was the voters’ message. Let’s see if our political parties can find a way to a common solution.
By Emerson Lynn
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here