Will Vt. GOP flub its ‘if not now, when’ opportunity? Probably.

Posted

The Vermont House last week gave its veto-proof support to an $8.58 billion state budget and is in the process of adding another $130 million in spending specifically tied to housing, expanding Medicaid and Dr. Dynasaur and the state’s judicial system. Money for those three programs would be generated through proposed tax increases on high-income individuals, and corporations, and raised taxes on property transfers.

House Republicans have decried the spending levels as irresponsible and have warned the proposed tax hikes pose a threat to Vermont’s economy. House Democrats say the revenue is necessary if the state’s needs are to be met.

The friction between the two has become standard fare. Last session the House also passed the historic childcare legislation and a universal paid family leave bill. The Senate approved the child care bill but dropped the universal paid family leave portion. The Senate had made it clear to the House that the state’s economy didn’t have room to do both. 

That same dynamic may be in play this year. The House is more aggressive with its push for higher taxes than the Senate. Sen. Phil Baruth, Senate President Pro Team, has already let it be known that he has little interest in following the House’s example. He said the Senate would not likely support the new revenue proposals or the level of new spending proposed by the House. The in-between-the-lines message to the House is that Mr. Baruth is saving the House from itself, pointing out that the House’s excesses could be a problem for the party in the November general election.

House Republicans have sounded the alarm [see Rep. Pattie McCoy’s op-ed opposite this page] and view the political landscape tilting in their favor. It’s an “if not now, when” moment for Republicans. Vermonters are likely to get hit with a double-digit increase in their property taxes and proposed hikes in corporate and personal income taxes are the grist for the Republican mill. Gov. Phil Scott is the state’s most popular politician - and a Republican - but he’s on the tail end of his political career. If the Republicans are ever going to peel back the Democrats’ supermajority in the Legislature the effort would need to start now.

But Democrats can be excused for feeling confident. Vermont’s Republican Party is almost non-existent and has performed dreadfully in finding capable candidates for any legislative seat. The Republican Party is split between supporters of Mr. Scott and supporters of former president Donald Trump, a split that will extend through the general election. That split will be hard to overcome for Republicans who have neither the organization nor the money necessary to pose much of a threat to Democrats in most regions of the state.

As the titular head of the state’s Republican Party, the responsibility of finding candidates to challenge the Democrat’s stranglehold on the Legislature would fall to Mr. Scott. But going back 40-plus years, history shows that Republican governors have paid little attention, or mounted much of an effort to boost the ranks. This includes Mr. Scott, Jim Douglas, and Richard Snelling.

House Democrats see little reason to worry. And they may be right. Mr. Baruth and his followers in the Senate are choosing to find the middle ground, essentially saying why take the chance?

The smart money is on Mr. Baruth. He’s likely to prevail in pushing back on the level of spending and the House’s proposals to raise taxes on corporations, the wealthy, and property transfers. He understands the liability that comes from being labeled a high-tax state and is concerned about the impending double-digit increase in property taxes.

Until Republicans unite around Mr. Scott’s moderate political views, they will likely remain in the position they are in, which means remaining in the cheap seats in any political discussion of note. That would seem to be reason enough for the Republican Party to rethink its priorities and its leadership. 

If the past is any indication of the Republican Party’s ability, or willingness to adapt to today’s challenges, then we can expect little to change, meaning any chance of a strong two-party system in Vermont is remote. 

By Emerson Lynn 

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here