The question on people’s minds is whether President-elect Donald Trump will do what he said he would do.
That’s as true of Vermonters as anyone else. Quebec is a big trading partner with Vermont, will he slap a 25 percent tariff on Canadian products shipped across our border? Vermont is a border state and a pathway for illegal immigrants to cross from Canada into the United States. Will he follow through with his promise to declare a national emergency and use the nation’s military forces to deport the roughly 11 million people here illegally?
No one knows. What we do know is that Mr. Trump knows the ropes, he has been in the job before and he needn’t fret about running for another term. We also know he surrounds himself with people who will do his bidding and who will feed his appetite for power. And, finally, we know that Vermont is a small state and of little concern to him. [He would sell Vermont to the Canadians if he could get his price.]
What he does is, however, a concern to most of us. While Mr. Trump considers tariffs a way to generate revenue [like Canada will agree to pay us 25 percent more for everything we import from them], what typically happens is that the consumer [us] ends up paying the higher price.
The president-elect says the proposed tariff is in response to Canada being a gateway for drugs and having a porous border, allowing illegals to make their way into the United States.
It’s one thing for Mr. Trump to push for stronger border security along the Canadian border. It’s quite another to truly make a concerted effort to deport those undocumented immigrants who are already here.
That’s what concerns Vermonters. And it should. If all our undocumented workers were identified and then deported, our farmers - writ large - would be hard-pressed to keep their businesses open. A good share of our dairy industry depends on immigrant labor to get its milk to market. We’ve experienced a steep decline in the number of dairy farms in the past two decades; that decline would increase precipitously if our farmers lost the benefit of the undocumented workers.
While Mr. Trump contends that undocumented workers are filling jobs that could be filled with his “America first” approach, that’s not the case with Vermont’s dairy industry. Farmers can’t fill those jobs with locals. Everyone knows that. We also know that if you think food prices are high now, wait until the last of the immigrant labor is forced to head back home.
We’ve been here before. In Mr. Trump’s first term Vermont enacted Act 5, which forbid Vermont’s state agencies from sharing information about the state’s undocumented workers with federal authorities. That could be pushed further to include local police as well.
Gov. Phil Scott, not a Trump supporter, has let it be known that he’s still on the side of the immigrants in Vermont. He’s also not convinced the president will follow through with his mass deportation plans. He says Mr. Trump’s proposal is “unrealistic” and hopes his staff will have the common sense to convince Mr. Trump to change his focus.
Maybe.
It might be prudent for the governor to have a backup plan in case the president orders his troops to chase through Vermont’s snow-filled woods on Jan. 21, 2025. Then again….maybe the governor could invite him up.
By Emerson Lynn
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here