Will legislators respond to crisis in school and health care?

Posted

In last week’s 144-page consultancy report on the state of Vermont’s hospitals, it was recommended that four of the state’s 14 hospitals be “repurposed.” The hospitals are low-volume hospitals and each has been struggling financially for years, all on the state’s eastern border. 

The hospitals wanted nothing to do with the consultant’s recommendations, which were released at a Green Mountain Care Board meeting. The political forces in those same communities made it clear they would oppose any effort to close the hospitals’ doors or to change the hospitals’ missions.

Shocker. 

For these communities, the hospitals are often their economic centers. Shut them down and patients must travel further from home for their care. Shut them down and the communities lose what little hope they had to grow. 

We attach the same importance to our hospitals as we do schools. Don’t touch them. Let them be. 

But that’s Vermont’s core challenge, isn’t it?: We don’t deal with our issues, and when we do we don’t include the big stuff, like our hospitals and our schools. That reluctance has put us in today’s affordability bind. The affordability of our school system is challenged by the loss of 25,000 students. That’s what happens when, as a state, we flatline with our population and the percentage of our elderly climbs, which makes healthcare more expensive to deliver.

These are not present-day circumstances in Vermont, they have been in play for decades. At some point, they must be recognized. At some point, they must be dealt with. We can’t afford all the schools we have, a casualty of our student count decline. We can’t afford our current structure of health care delivery. And when we say we can’t afford it, that means we can’t afford it along with everything else our legislators appropriate to spend elsewhere.

What is different about last week’s report on our hospitals - and on health care in general - is the timing. It came just as the Green Mountain Care Board [GMCB] had cut almost all the state’s hospitals’ proposed budgets, and months prior, had given Blue Cross Blue Shield premium increases of roughly 22 percent. The report made it clear that if current trends continue all our hospitals will need massive levels of subsidization within three years.

That is a declaration of emergency if there ever was one. The consultant also wrote that the number one responsibility of GMCB going forward is to: “Permit no further increases in commercial subsidization for hospital financial shortfalls.”

In other words, hospitals need to fix what ails them or face financial burdens beyond anything they have yet experienced. The state’s regulator is not willing to subsidize a hospital’s operations.

A little over three months remains before the Legislature convenes. Given the enormity of the issues raised - all dealing with the high cost of living and working in Vermont - it would seem axiomatic that our legislators would focus on what needs to happen with our schools and what happens with our healthcare system. Almost to the exclusion of all other issues.

You would think. But both issues come with hard choices and it’s easier for politicians to duck them than try to solve them. That’s one of the reasons we are where we are. To change that will require an issue that takes us to the edge, to that point where it’s political malpractice to ignore it.

The Oliver Wyman consultancy’s report on Vermont’s hospitals may hold the information and the recommendations necessary to make it the issue it should be. That will depend on who does the best job of getting their message out to Vermonters.

We will soon see.

By Emerson Lynn

   

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here