If people could choose between a one percent jump in the rate of inflation or a one percent increase in unemployment, they would, according to the polls, pick a higher unemployment rate even though that would mean an additional 1.7 million people without jobs.
Insensitive? Yes, but not shocking. People protect themselves before being sympathetic to others. And, academics are learning that although inflation has moderated substantially, people still think prices are too high and resent it. The continual need to rejigger our budgets and to live within our means is exhausting, let alone dispiriting. It is like watching someone taking money out of your wallet with no ability to stop them.
It affects us all, particularly those on limited or fixed incomes, which has an outsized effect in states like Vermont, the second oldest state in the nation. People here count their pennies; they need to.
Which brings us to the political side of the equation. Higher costs, particularly year after year, invite retribution. Voters begin to identify the culprits, typically those in power. Polls show a majority of voters blame President Biden for today’s inflation, and a majority think Donald Trump would better handle the economy.
Which is why Gov. Phil Scott continues to ride the affordability theme and why he recently vetoed the “yield” bill that would have raised property taxes 13.8 percent to pay for our schools.
The governor does not have a better idea. In fact, the alternative he proposed during the session - to borrow money to bring down the tax rate - was much worse and less fiscally defensible than the bill the Legislature passed and the governor just vetoed.
It did not matter. He knows full well the Legislature will most likely override his veto. He will not put himself in the position of being an accomplice to legislation that will raise property tax bills by almost 14 percent.
This moment may be a pivotal one for Vermont and for the Legislature. If the governor is truly concerned about Vermont’s “affordability” then he will need to do more than use the theme for himself alone. He will need to use his popularity to bring other Republicans into the fold. Not only will he need to take a chunk out of the Democrats’ supermajority he needs to raise enough money to give Republican candidates a chance to win their races. Having a governor reach beyond his or her own campaign is something we have not seen since before Richard Snelling in the 1980s.
The difference between prior gubernatorial races and Mr. Scott’s is that he has no real competition. Any money he raises could be used to support like-minded candidates. Will he? We’ll see. If so, it will need to extend beyond this year’s campaign - since the deadline for Legislative seats has passed.
To add to the challenge, six of the 30 state senators have either died or announced their retirements, and they were the Senate's stalwarts, people who had served in the Senate a long, long time. Their replacements will likely be much younger and more focused on current, more progressive issues. Keeping in mind that we are represented in Washington by Rep. Becca Balint, Sen. Peter Welch, and Sen. Bernie Sanders - all liberals with strong statewide organizations, Mr. Scott doesn’t have a lot of space in which to maneuver.
Vermonters are feeling picked upon when it comes to how much it costs to live in Vermont. In fact, it is the only major issue on their radar, something that resonates with them daily. When people’s property tax bills come due, the temperature of the state’s political environment will ratchet upwards. The governor knows this and he is well insulated from the voters’ ire because of his opposition. The question is whether he has the means and the willingness to bring his message beyond his race.
The opportunity is there. People want costs to decline. But for the governor's message to reach beyond himself, he will need to expand his campaign beyond affordability to workable alternatives to what is being passed by the Legislature.
By Emerson Lynn
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here