By year’s end, Vermonters may look back to this week for a fuller understanding as to why the Green Mountain Care Board and its chair, Owen Foster, decided to take on the University of Vermont Medical Center, the 800-pound gorilla that dominates Vermont’s health care system.
By then, it’s expected that Congress will end the subsidies for the Affordable Care Act, which means the 32,000 Vermonters who get their health insurance from Vermont Health Connect will see a double-digit price increase. For some, the increase could be 50 percent or higher. Another 49,000 Vermonters on Medicaid are at risk of losing coverage. Fifty percent of Vermonters who get their health insurance from their employers are still at risk of facing a stiff increase themselves.
The general public has yet to focus on that reality, and when it happens, they will react predictably. They will want to know why.
The GMCB does understand what lies ahead. So does Gov. Phil Scott, who recently issued a statement saying: “The fact is, like in education, well-intentioned policies Vermonters were promised would make things better and more affordable are not working as intended, and many have become counterproductive. The status quo has allowed unacceptable amounts of administrative cost growth, unbearable pricing strategies, and perverse financial incentives and executive bonuses paid for by skyrocketing premiums.”
The governor directed his comments at UVMMC and the University of Vermont Health Network. He was following up on Mr. Foster’s testimony, in which he said, “University of Vermont Health Network does not provide health care. It’s essentially an expensive and ineffective layer of overpriced and unnecessary corporate bureaucracy that has proven itself both physically and spiritually distant and unconnected from the mission of our flagship academic medical center and the needs of Vermont.”
Wow. That’s quite a slap.
All of this came about within the last week or so. Yesterday, University of Vermont Health Network’s Board of Trustees announced that Sunny Eappen, president and CEO would step down. Mr. Eappen said, “But I believe - based on everything that’s happening and all of the external pressures on our rural health system - that this organization needs to move forward in a different way.”
The pressure for Mr. Eappen to leave came from the UVMMC board’s pressure on the University of Vermont Health Network board of directors, and the pressure on UVMMC came from Mr. Foster and his blistering assessment of how UVMMC and UVMHN are being run and what the impact is on Vermont’s health care system and on Vermonters who are being priced out of their health care coverage. Things have to change.
The crux of Mr. Foster’s complaint is that Vermonters are being forced to cover the costs of the three hospitals in upstate New York that are owned by UVMMC and operated by the UVMHN. In Mr. Foster’s testimony, he detailed how the hospital’s “corporate shell game” was set up to “shift” money to UVMHN, which would make the medical center’s profit margins and reserves less than they really are. That would put Vermont’s rate payers in the position of making up the difference. Mr. Foster said UVMHN “deprives UVMMC of over $100 million by using Vermont reserves to pay New York hospitals’ expenses.” Mr. Foster has suggested that there is upwards of $40 million in unnecessary costs associated with the UVMHN process.
That’s a lot of money that Vermonters are being asked to pay hospitals based in New York, not Vermont. That’s a lot of money that isn’t available to our own hospitals, which are in the midst of their own struggles. And, as we cited earlier, these are costs that will compound the burden toward the end of the year if Congress reduces its funding to the states.
All of this explains, in part, why the governor, the GMCB, the Liaison Group headed by Mike Smith, and the Vermont Department of Financial Regulation are focused on the cost of health care. The UVMMC and the UVMHN are at the center of this focus because that’s where the money is. If it’s being misspent, the bill falls to Vermonters. If it’s being misspent, it weakens other parts of the state’s healthcare system.
It’s a story that’s only partially understood because it’s complicated and still unfolding. Questions linger. If UVM’s hospitals in New York are losing money and Vermonters are being forced to pay the bills, then what’s the better way forward?
Stay tuned. The ride ahead will be a bumpy one.
By Emerson Lynn
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here