In a little over a month, the Vermont Legislature will resume its work, the results of which voters will judge on Nov. 5. It’s the Legislature - and the governor - who give us a sense of direction and their interpretation of what is a priority and what is not.
It should be obvious before the opening session that we are near the end of the affordability spectrum. We’ve spent what’s available, and the appetite for raising taxes, even on the better off among us, does not exist.
Vermonters are also starved for progress on the fundamental issues that face us, king among them is responsible growth. It’s difficult for our communities - writ large - to maintain, let alone improve their offerings if we continue to lose popu- lation and fail to attract new businesses.
The Legislature can’t snap its fingers to bring growth to Vermont’s communities, but it can help clear the path for communities to do a better job on their own. One such effort legislators will consider this year is allowing municipalities to bypass Act 250 review at the state level and judge local development projects on their own.
It seems like a small, logical step for a state that needs something bigger and more immediate. But we don’t do big, nor do we move fast. We struggle with issues of trust, and, frankly, change. That’s why Act 250 has remained largely intact in its half century life span.
But the need to change is evident in our lack of growth and our inability to build homes with any speed, or scale. It’s evident in having lot sizes that are far and away larger than in any of the 50 states. We talk about affordability but don’t do anything about it. We talk about how ideal it would be to bring growth to Vermont’s towns’ centers, but talk is all we do.
In a recent Messenger guest editorial Catherine Dimitruk, executive director of Northwest Regional Planning Commission made the case for how it would work for cities like St. Albans to assume the responsibility of charting how growth would be handled in our planned growth areas.
It’s hardly the stuff that constitutes revolt. To be allowed that responsibility, communities must demonstrate they have strong local development regulations, the same rigorous standards embodied by Act 250. There are only a half dozen municipalities that meet those standards, St. Albans City being one. It makes no sense to force developers to go through additional steps when only one is necessary.
Ms. Dimitruk is a credible proponent of the proposed change because she is trusted. Her decades-long tenure gives her the credibility legislators need when considering such a change. She’s a strong proponent of responsible growth and has an environmentalist’s sentiment when it comes to what’s appropriate growth for a community. She can speak for Franklin County because she’s earned the county’s trust and respect. That should be what legislators seek when considering the tweak in Act 250 that will be proposed.
As Ms. Dimitruk argues, the proposed legislation “allows for vibrant economic development, improved social connections, and maximizes the return on public investment in infrastructure. One way to encourage the growth we need, where we want it, is to eliminate unnecessary regulations.”
Spot on.
As straightforward as Ms. Dimitruk’s logic is, it will be a fight to get the legislation passed. In a recent Vermont Public story, Brian Shupe, executive direct of the Vermont Natural Resources Council, said the idea was a poor one and something his organization would oppose. “Act 250 is really designed to take a step back from just the community level and take a regional approach to looking at the larger scale development projects. To make it a little bit more politically independent of local governments and to protect state resources. I don’t think we can always trust the municipalities to do that.”
And there you go: Mr. Shupe’s lack of trust in Ms. Dimitruk’s belief and unparalleled understanding of Act 250 and the City of St. Albans’s commitment to responsible growth. Mr. Shupe is opposed because he wants things to remain as they are. No change. Ms. Dimitruk favors the change because she knows the city’s standards are as high as those in Act 250 and that ridding ourselves of unnecessary regulations can lower the cost of housing and pave the way for new and responsible growth. Our example, if allowed, could pave the way for others.
One would hope the Legislature would side with the Ms. Dimitruks of Vermont, understanding that standing still, refusing to consider change, solves nothing. Mr. Shupe is looking backwards, Ms. Dimitruk is looking forward.
Not a difficult choice.
By Emerson Lynn
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here