Politics is largely the exercise of staying in one’s lane. For obvious reasons. When the practice is abridged, people notice, the party’s leadership cries foul. The chattering class sifts through the tea leaves in search of meaning. All this was in play this week when former Gov. Peter Shumlin broke ranks with his endorsement of Republican John Rodgers for Lieutenant Governor.
Mr. Rodgers’ race against incumbent Proogressive David Zuckerman is the only statewide race in Vermont that is even close to being contested. It’s also the only statewide race that has generated the nastiness we see on the national stage. Which is why Mr. Shumlin’s endorsement has drawn so much attention.
Why would a devoted Democrat like Mr. Shumlin endorse any Republican knowing the person at the top of the ticket, Donald Trump, is so reviled in Vermont? And is his endorsement significant?
It is significant, but probably less so for Mr. Rodgers than it is a signal that Mr. Zuckerman’s political reach may top out in the position he’s in. He’s a favorite of the progressives but much less so of mainline Democrats, of which Mr. Shumlin is a charter member. Mr. Zuckerman has already played his hand in a 2020 race for governor against Republican Phil Scott. He lost in a landslide. Democrats are searching for someone who has a better chance of winning the governorship should Mr. Scott not seek a sixth term.
There is also a sense of ennui that surrounds Mr. Zuckerman and his political ambitions. He’s a well-to-do gentleman farmer who appears content to sit in place until the right opportunity presents itself. In other words, someone who is more interested in the office than the responsibility that comes with it.
That explains Mr. Shumlin’s observation: “Let’s remember that one of them’s a Democrat, and the other one’s a Progressive, in my view.” Mr. Rodgers served in the Legislature for nearly two decades and did so as a Democrat. He switched parties saying the Democrats had moved too far left, in line with Progressives, a tune that resonates with Mr. Shumlin.
Although it’s no surprise that Mr. Rodgers also has the support of Mr. Scott and former Gov. Jim Douglas, it’s Mr. Shumlin’s endorsement that holds the potential for Mr. Rodgers. The political middle is where races are won or lost. If Mr. Rodgers has the money to bring Mr. Shumlin’s endorsement to the voters’ attention, he could sway some of the more conservative Democrats to his corner.
Mr. Shumlin’s endorsement and the general ire voters express about Vermont’s high cost of living - including this year’s 14 percent increase in property taxes - could be a deciding factor in next Tuesday’s general election.
Although it’s an uphill battle in Vermont to unseat any incumbent - Mr. Zuckerman included - Mr. Shumlin’s endorsement of Mr. Rogers may have a notable impact going forward. It’s a clear message being sent by a three-term, Democratic governor that the storm clouds on the state’s horizon are mounting and that we have challenges that will demand a change in course from Mr. Zuckerman and his ilk.
At least Mr. Shumlin has the courage to say so.
By Emerson Lynn
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here