Why it's important that you know

Posted

There are 300 million reasons the University of Vermont Health Network did not want Mike Smith and his Liaison Team poring through their books. That’s the amount of money UVM must cut from its budget over the next three years, money Mr. Smith’s healthcare experts identified as being imprudently spent.

The Liason Team came into being in April, 2025, born out of the controversy between the Green Mountain Care Board and the UVM Health Network. UVM was accused of overcharging Blue Cross Blue Shield of Vermont. There was also a simmering battle between the hospital and the GMCB over its leadership and its cost of doing business, among other things.

The hospital agreed to pay $12 million to BCBSVT to settle the overcharging issue. The big step forward was the agreement by both sides to put in place the Liaison Team, whose purpose was to examine the hospital network’s financial health and determine whether the hospital’s claims of affordability matched what was happening. [Mr. Smith, a critic of the hospital, was not UVM’s choice, to say the least.]

That “deep dive” has been underway for over a year. The Liaison Team was granted unprecedented access to UVM’s internal data, which has allowed it to examine the network’s budget proposals and all operations dealing with issues of affordability, access, and quality of care.

The good news is that UVM’s leadership has changed since the liaison team formation, and it has publicly embraced the work of Mr. Smith and his team. UVM Health President and CEO Steve Leffler was quoted as saying, “At the highest level, we support the key findings of the report. It’s good for the patients that we serve and will help with access and affordability.”

That’s a dramatic turnaround in attitude from the hospital’s prior administration.

But, as the team’s report this week noted, identifying the issues and dealing with them are two different things. The headline challenge was for the hospital to find $100 million to cut from its budget each year for the next three years. Although that’s only 2.8 percent of its budget, it’s still enough to challenge how the hospital functions.

That’s part of the issue. Equally important is recognizing the hospital’s flaws and then correcting them. King among those flaws is the hospital’s poor standing among its peers for the length of time a patient must wait to be seen. According to the liaison team’s investigation, the average patient at UVM waits 96 days for an appointment. A patient who needs a referral waits 104 days. A report from the American Academy of Family Physicians found that the average wait for a patient nationally was 23 days. UVM is far below the 50th percentile when compared to its national peers.

According to Mr. Smith’s team, the responsibility for much of this falls on the shoulders of physicians and scheduling systems. This low level of productivity is not only costly, but it also contributes to poor levels of health care. It was noted that if UVM’s physicians were able to reach the 50 percent productivity level of other hospitals, it would “enable 26% more clinical services to be performed” and they could “produce the current volume of patient care with 78 fewer clinical FTEs.”

And that’s at a productivity level of 50 percent, which doesn’t sound like a high bar.

The liaison team’s work was also notable for verifying what we already know and feel: Something has to be done. What we have is not affordable. Unsubsidized premiums and deductions consume 32.2 percent of the median individual household income in Vermont and 41.8 percent of the median family household income. Little wonder Vermonters feel underwater with their daily costs.

UVM Health Network is the 800-pound gorilla. If costs are ever to be moderated, UVM must be that catalyst for change.

Here’s our worry. Mr. Smith and his liaison team will finish their work this fall. They have no legal authority to enforce what they suggest. That authority rests with the Green Mountain Care Board, which is understaffed and subject to leadership changes. No money is set aside to keep Vermonters informed or motivated to push for continued improvements.

When Vermonters are subject to health care costs that consume such a large portion of their disposable income, shouldn’t we put in place a system that keeps us informed, a system that keeps us on track with Mr. Smith’s team’s suggestions, an adequately funded system that protects the integrity of the Green Mountain Care Board and its direction?

It’s a truism that we are only as good as the people who lead us, and, for the moment, we’re fortunate to have that leadership. But we need to be looking beyond. And we need to be doing a far better job informing Vermonters as to what’s happening, why it’s happening, and why it’s important they know.

By Emerson Lynn

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here