The headline reads: “New England schools are failing - and ‘nobody seems to care.’” The Oct. 1, 2025, story was written by Boston Globe reporter Christopher Huffaker, and he took direct aim at Vermont, whose educational system has fallen from being one of the nation’s top four to being ranked near the bottom. In the last decade,no state has fallen as far as Vermont in its early reading test results.
According to the National Report Card, the national average in Grade 4 reading scores declined by seven percent. Vermont’s decline was a negative 17 percent. In Grade 8 math scores, the national average was a decline of eight percent. Vermont’s decline was a negative 15 percent. Meanwhile, according to Mr. Huffaker’s reporting, Mississippi and Louisiana, among the poorest states in the nation, led all others in their results, far outpacing the national average, and miles ahead of us in Vermont.
New England’s decline is being compared by Mr. Huffaker to the “Southern Surge” that includes Alabama, Louisiana, and Mississippi. How is it, he asks, that Vermont can spend so much more per student than its southern brethren and yet do so much worse in both reading and math? How is it that the “Southern Surge” states have embraced their National Report Card results as a badge of honor, and Vermont - along with other New England states - has developed the reputation of “not caring” about their failing scores?
Good question.
The good news is that the Globe’s story got the attention of the Vermont Agency of Education. Secretary of Education Zoie Saunders responded by saying, “As an education leader and as a parent of school-aged children, these are difficult words to read. However, we need to own the reality that Vermont can do a better job of serving our students and supporting our teachers, particularly in rural and economically disadvantaged areas of the state.”
The response also included a quote from Dr. Erin Davis, the Agency’s Chief Academic Officer: “…I know how important it is that we resist the urge to assign blame and instead recognize that many of our toughest challenges are deeply systemic.”
Interesting. If we had an educational system rated in the top four nationally a decade ago, what changed? What could we have done that would have pushed our educational system all the way to the bottom in such a short amount of time?
And why is no one angry about it? All that money for dismal results?
Mr. Huffaker’s investigative report points out that Mississippi and Louisiana saw that they were in a crisis and did something about it. They put money into instruction. They changed the programs they were teaching. They held children back if they didn’t meet the standards. And they made their cause something that registered with the people in their state. All of them.
In other words, Vermont has rested on its laurels. We’ve assumed that what we had in place would be enough, that change wasn’t necessary. Vermont’s demand for local control precludes it from looking at the system as a whole, which means there is no statewide strategy in place to correct our decline in test scores. Every school district is on its own.
That’s not to say there isn’t a lot going on within the state’s educational landscape. To the contrary, it’s in the process of being changed, perhaps dramatically. An effort is underway to redraw and reduce the number of school districts and to figure out a new way to pay the bill. The collateral value could be class sizes that are better suited for instruction and improved educational opportunities. The hope is that it also reduces the cost of education in general.
That’s the plan. And it’s centered around affordability, which, as we know, is the one word around which Vermonters are oriented.
But, as Mr. Huffaker makes clear, that’s not enough. The states that are scoring above all others are the ones that have “refused to accept mediocrity.” Vermont needs to do the same. We have 51 school districts, but we can’t have 51 separate voices. We need to speak as one when it comes to being included, once again, as a state with one of the nation’s best school systems.
It’s a travesty we’ve allowed the slide toward the bottom to happen. The only thing worse would be to allow it to continue.
By Emerson Lynn
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here