By the end of this month or early September, healthcare consultants are to release a set of recommendations to follow if Vermont is to successfully address the state’s failing healthcare system.
Bruce Hamory, a doctor and consultant with the firm Oliver Wyman, was quoted this week as saying, “You’re going to get about 150 suggestions-plus with fairly detailed recommendations.” The goal is to have made significant process within the next five years.
We have been here before, just on a smaller scale. In December 2014, Gov. Peter Shumlin abandoned his plan for single-payer health care, saying it wasn’t affordable and that moving in that direction raised the potential for “economic disruption.” And here we are a decade later staring at today’s “economic disruption” with no real plan for how to go forward.
A lot has happened in the interim. We’ve grown older and sicker as a state. Our population has stagnated. The Covid virus turned the healthcare system upside down. Medical inflation has run rampant. Hospital staffing has become a nightmare and all the state’s hospitals are expected to be operating in the red by 2028. In the consultant’s report, Vermont’s hospitals would need an additional $1.4 billion over the next five years to achieve a three percent operating margin assuming a growth in expenses of five percent.
That’s a lot.
Vermonters know. They have been paying a lot.
The consultants tell us what we have is not sustainable. Again, we know.
But throwing 150 suggestions at us doesn’t sound like a plan. And leading with ideas like “more housing” isn’t terribly helpful, unless someone identifies where the money comes from, and where the housing would be built.
What we have is a mess, but it’s also a mess that concerns 20 percent of Vermont’s economy and a king-size portion of the state’s employment picture. It’s a mess that affects all 647,064 Vermonters. If not done right, this “transformation” can make things worse. [As impossible as that might sound.]
It’s also a given that whatever is done will require patience. It took a long time to get where we are and it will take a long time to finally develop a healthcare system that meets the public’s needs at an affordable price. And it may not happen. The odds are not in our favor. Our health care system is highly politicized and any change can be expected to be opposed from advocates within and outside the system.
So who guides us? Who takes responsibility for charting the path forward? Who sets the priorities? Who tells the story? Who creates that sense of urgency, or that sense of allegiance to moving forward?
Telling the story is essential. The consultants crisscrossed the state to educate Vermonters as to the health care crisis we face. They had about 2,800 people show up, which is about four out of every thousand Vermonters. In other words, very few of us know what’s happening, why, and what can be done.
If we can’t figure out how to weave the 150 or so suggestions into a coherent package that makes sense, then the efforts of the consultants will be for naught. The healthcare system will continue its slide toward a deeper peril, which leaves us fewer, and fewer options. That’s what typically happens.
So, instead of the consulting firm dropping its 150-plus suggestions on our plate and wishing us good luck, how about figuring out how to spread the word to Vermonters in a way that elicits their support, raising hopes that our health care crisis will be dealt with?
By Emerson Lynn
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here