When things go wrong silence is unacceptable

Posted

The call for us to walk in the shoes of others before judgment is as old as humankind. It’s the key to empathy. And tolerance. It’s how we move productive conversations forward and challenge the unproductive. But for its lessons to resonate means being public with what we see and hear and what we know to be right. 

That was the message sent to Vermonters this week by the Winooski School Board following the detention of their superintendent, Wilmer Chavarria, at the George Bush Intercontinental Airport on Monday. 

“The Winooski School Board calls upon all Vermonters - and all Americans - to stand in solidarity with Superintendent Chavarria and his family. We urge our elected leaders and federal agencies to investigate this incident and take meaningful steps to prevent such abuses from continuing.

“While we are aware that such detentions are increasingly becoming more common across the country, we must be clear: this is not normal. It is wrong. It is inhumane. It is unjust,” the board said in a statement.

Seven Days and Vermont Digger have detailed stories about the travails of Mr. Chavarria and his husband, Cyrus Dudgeon, as they returned to the U.S. from Nicaragua. Mr. Chavarria was visiting his family, as he has done routinely over the past 21 years. He’s been a citizen of the United States since 2018. Never before had he been questioned.

On Monday, immigration officials singled him out of the Global Entry Pass line, which, ironically, is used by those who are pre-approved and viewed as low risk. And who could be lower risk than someone who is a superintendent, a documented U.S. citizen for seven years, and someone who attended college here and has two graduate degrees, one from Harvard?

Couldn’t he be quickly seen as one of the good guys, the type we’d like to have amongst us?

Apparently not. As Mr. Chavarria has detailed, he was detained for over five hours, aggressively questioned in what he called a “surreal” and “dehumanizing” experience. He was never told why he was detained. He was told they didn’t believe his claim of being a superintendent. They told him he did not have any rights. The authorities demanded access to his phone, laptop, and accompanying passwords. And, as you might expect, they mocked the validity of his 15-year marriage. He was denied legal help. He was not allowed to make a phone call. 

Oh, and need we add that the color of his skin - brown - should be added to the list.

Mr. Chavarria refused their request for full access to his computer. He’s a superintendent bound by the Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act that protects the privacy of student education records. They threatened to have him removed from his job.

Five hours later, he was released, long past the connecting flight home to Burlington. It was never explained to him why he was detained. On Tuesday, he opened his email only to find that his yearlong Global Entry pass had been revoked.

The experience has made Mr. Chavarria reticent to make a return trip to see his elderly mother anytime soon. He knows what happened on Monday could easily happen again. “It’s not about immigration status, really. It’s about being Black and brown immigrants,” he said.

No one argues that our borders were unduly porous in the years before this administration. And no one argues that we should not be diligent about making sure that those who do immigrate here are not coming with questionable intent. 

But Mr. Chavarria’s bonafides are beyond question, as any immigration official with a modicum of common sense could see if the effort were made. What happened to Mr. Chavarria was wrong. What happened to him was obviously racist. What happened to him needs to be ferreted out by our Congressional delegation and made public. The action by immigration officials at the airport in Houston has no defense. It also demolishes the administration’s contention that it is acting in the best interests of the American public.

To say nothing creates the inertia that weakens us all. The Winooski School Board is right. Walk in Mr. Chavarria’s shoes. Say something. 

By Emerson Lynn 

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here