What Vt. can do for its relationship with Quebec

Posted

Thoughtfulness is an investment that never fails and in Vermont’s relationship with Quebec, it's something that will provide a return for those who are patient.

It’s a means of correcting false impressions. It's a way to express comfort with our own truth. The importance of that thoughtfulness is that when the page of history is turned it will be remembered for its constancy and steadfastness.

When President Trump belittled Canadians by saying they would be better off as our nation's 51st state he gave them every reason to show their self-sufficiency. When he slapped large tariffs on Canadian goods he put a price tag on cooperation. It was a power play and, again, he made it easy for Canadians to show their independence. They've stayed home in larger numbers than anyone could have thought.

The difficulty for Vermont is that Quebec is our largest trading partner. We depend on them for part of our well-being. For those of us in Franklin County the connection with those just across the border is often familial. The border has never been intended as a fence.

When the tariffs were announced, the hope was that they would be short in duration. Or that the impact would be less than feared.

That has not been the case. Canadian traffic at the border has been almost 25 percent less than normal. Businesses that depend on Canadian traffic are suffering. A Messenger story by Publisher and Editor Bridget Higdon quoted Jason Chartrand, from Montgomery, as saying “This administration has stepped over a line, and it is going to be really hard for us to recover our relationship that we’ve enjoyed for decades.”

In other words, it less about the money than it is how you treat someone. Pretty basic. But the timing is unfortunate, to say the least. After literally decades of work, Quebec is about to complete Autoroute A-35. Finally, travelers on both sides of the border will have a direct line from Montreal to Vermont’s Interstate 89. It has long been estimated that the road’s completion would trigger a 30 percent increase in Canadian visitation. 

That would be a big boost to northwestern Vermont’s economy.

One day…

Franklin County State Senator Randy Brock sponsored resolution S.R. 11 honoring the “historic, integrated and productive relations” between Quebec and Vermont. It also called upon the Trump administration to dispense with the tariffs.

As Mr. Brock was quoted as saying, “What we need to do locally is communicate to our counterparts across the border our commitment to maintain close relations and to indicate that we’re the ones who deal with you every day. The people in Washington don’t necessarily do that.”

Mr. Brock said the state’s tourism and commerce departments should use everything in their arsenals to promote tourism between Vermont and Quebec.

He’s correct. And it would be easy to do. There are countless ways to reach Quebec with a message of friendship. They need to hear that what comes from our nation’s capital does not reflect our values or our beliefs. A clever campaign might even trigger a small wave of Quebecers who’ve missed their Vermont fix. 

It also works in reverse. The state’s campaign could also encourage Vermonters to step across the border with a full wallet. That would be a nice twist on the president’s interpretation of the word “reciprocal.”

The point is, being thoughtful isn’t something to be delayed. We should not be waiting for Quebecers to say they are willing to allow bygones to be bygones. They didn’t start the war of words. We want them to remember that when this does pass - and it will - that Vermont had long ago offered its own words of friendship.

That's not only honorable, but good business.

By Emerson Lynn

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here