For a quarter century, we have been expressing alarm about the precipitous decline in our school-age population. And for a quarter century, Vermont has done little to nothing about it. This failure has cost us in two key ways: it has made our school system one of the nation’s most expensive, and it has contributed to our school system’s decline in academic standing. That’s a problematic combination.
When we first wrote about this predicted decline in 1998, the state had a peak student population of roughly 105,000. Demographers warned of the pending decline. They forecast a drop of 20 percent, plateauing in 2025. If only. Instead, we now have a 73,000-student population, a 30 percent drop, and demographers predict the steep decline to continue. A Seven Days story offered the headline: “Vermont’s School Enrollment Is Dropping at an Alarming Rate.”
That aside, we still have the same basic infrastructure we had in 1998, when our enrollment peaked. [Franklin County has followed this decline, just at a lesser rate. We had a student population of 11,000-11,500 in 1998, which has dropped to 8,800-9,100 in 2025, which is roughly a 20 percent decline.]
The “golden era” for the state’s academic standing followed its peak enrollment years. Between 2002-2011 Vermont was consistently ranked among the nation’s top five states on its NAEP proficiency rates. Our test scores began to plateau between 2013 and 2017 and then began their sharp decline between 2019 and 2025.
Our 15-year decline in literacy and math proficiency pairs with our population decline. It’s both correlation and causation. As enrollment drops, the cost to keep our schools open increases, which means less money goes to the innovation necessary to bring test scores up. Our smallest schools struggle to attract and keep highly qualified teachers. That explains, in part, why our proficiency in Grade 8 reading has fallen from 40 percent proficient to 29 percent. It explains, in part, why we’ve fallen a full grade and a half in reading proficiency since 2015.
For parents with school-aged children, that’s not a feel-good. Paying more and getting less never is.
So, the plan is what?
Rep. Peter Conlin, D-Cornwall, is chair of House Committee on Education and has been heavily involved in the effort to consolidate the state’s 119 school districts. While Gov. Phil Scott is pushing to reduce the number of districts to five, Mr. Conlin proposes to cut the number to 27. As Mr. Conlon notes, his proposal is a conversation starter, not the final product.
This isn’t Mr. Conlon’s first rodeo negotiating the ups and downs of Vermont’s educational system. And fundamental to his belief is the fact that Vermont has too many schools and that a sizable number need to be closed. Period. Full stop.
How could it be otherwise when we have lost 30 percent of our student population, and we are one of five states whose total population count is in decline, and our rate of decline last year was the nation’s steepest?
Then, there’s this: Our schools are old and in need of repair. Some desperately. The estimated bill is over $6 billion. More importantly, an estimated $400 million needs to be spent this year to keep up with the cycle of repairs and replacement for 384 schools.
We haven’t had a formal state-funded school construction aid program since 2007. So, the money comes from where?
One of the key parts of Act 73 is that the state will rank proposed construction based on a point system that ensures the proposed projects merge schools or districts to save money. The proposed projects would also need to align with the state’s educational quality standards, which means that schools with too few students would have a more difficult time getting their projects approved. The state would also factor in class sizes.
That’s a key provision of the law, which takes effect on July 1, 2026, unless it’s changed. To Mr. Conlin’s point, is this not the time for the Legislature and the Agency of Education to list those schools that, absent a resurgence in population, would not qualify for construction aid? Wouldn’t that make a difference to the school-closure debate if the voters in those towns knew in advance that it would be unlikely for them to fix their dilapidated schools?
The demographic challenge faced by our school system is, like the headline suggests, “alarming” and unlikely to reverse itself. What would make it worse is if we continued to ignore the fundamentals of the debate and did nothing. We keep pretending that, at some point, rural Vermont will be discovered and people will flock to our quaint rural schools, bringing us the growth that we need to prosper. That’s the argument that keeps our smallest schools open, despite the evidence to the contrary.
Talk about alarming.
By Emerson Lynn
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here