When the founders of the Constitution addressed the right to vote it was not without trepidation. How does a government exercise its powers from the “consent of the governed” when so much can go wrong and so much hangs in the balance?
Who should vote, and how? That right of suffrage is considered a fundamental Article, yet it was then, and remains, a delicate task to administer, as our last presidential election showed.
For 200 years plus, we have addressed the inequities, and we have toiled to make our elections fair and open. But the challenges remain.
Vermont is a textbook illustration of one: Having its citizens care enough to vote.
In Vermont’s August primary, the final tally showed 15 percent of Vermont’s eligible voters bothered to vote. How does a democracy function when 85 out of every 100 eligible voters are okay with having the remaining 15 choose who should govern us?
The counter to that is that it’s the primary, and it’s of less importance than the general election which attracts a higher percentage of voters, particularly in a presidential election year.
That’s accurate in terms of total numbers. It’s less accurate if you consider the non-voting impact on how Vermonters are governed. We are essentially a one-party state. The Democrats have a veto-proof majority in both the House and Senate and fill the ranks in all statewide elected offices with the exception of the governor. That plays to the distinct advantage of incumbents, who can rely on name recognition to win. The smaller the turnout the more likely it is that the incumbent’s base will make the difference.
That was essentially the case in the primary. Almost no one showed up. The ones who did voted for the people they knew. Incumbents prevailed. And because the Republicans - as a party - are so weak we pretty much know the complexion of the Legislature after the primary in August. We also can predict today who will be our statewide officials, and we can do so with great confidence. There is little to no competition for any of the statewide positions.
Is this all explained because Vermont’s challenges have been met and Vermonters see no reason to change those who govern on their behalf?
Probably not. Our school system is a mess. Our healthcare industry is running deeply in the red. We have no available housing and the housing that is available is expensive. Our population is stagnating and getting older by the minute. We are on everyone’s list as a place that’s too expensive to live and work.
Why aren’t we the poster child for a state in need of its best minds working on its most difficult issues?
It’s probably true that most thinking people have been turned off to the political process and want no part of it. It’s too easy to be vilified on social media, making the experience something most would rather not deal with. Legislators also get paid little and are asked to do a lot. That gives the job a poor cost-benefit ratio appeal. It’s better to sack groceries.
We all have a hand in this. it’s easier to be critical than supportive. It’s easier to tear things down than it is to build things back up. And, as the primary results indicated, it’s easiest just to ignore it all, letting the few govern the many, complaining, but not participating.
It’s interesting that we set up blue-ribbon panels to recommend how to move forward with a new funding mechanism for our schools, how to improve and strengthen our healthcare system, and how to address our housing issues, and lack of growth, yet we don’t expend any energy or thought to how we can govern ourselves more broadly and effectively.
August’s primary numbers should make is think otherwise.
By Emerson Lynn
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here