When the Vermont Department of Taxes issued its annual “December 1 letter” forecasting an 18.5 percent increase in residents’ property tax rates, Gov. Phil Scott said what Vermonters would expect, that the increase was unacceptable. Ruinous, in fact. The state’s Democratic leadership called the governor out for creating worry, saying the tools were available to make the increase palatable to homeowners.
That was early December, long before the governor’s office or the Legislature had the necessary data to draw meaningful conclusions. The information the Department of Taxes did have showed schools with spending increases totaling just over 12 percent, which is the highest spending increase ever recorded.
This week, the rest of the data became available, representing the lion’s share of school spending. Instead of a 12 percent increase in spending, the total was 14.84 percent - a 23.6 percent increase.
That means the 18.5 percent increase that was projected on Dec. 1 has popped up to 20.59, an 11 percent increase.
Vermont has shouldered through its share of property tax hikes. But not a leap of 20 percent. It’s doubtful any state is looking at a 20 percent increase in its property tax rate. We’re proud to lead the nation in a variety of categories; this isn’t one of them.
This is not a partisan issue. Not at this level. Democrats and Republicans - even Progressives - are keenly aware of the political repercussions should residents’ property taxes be increased 20 percent.
But what should be done, how, and by what amount is now the question that consumes Montpelier. By session’s end the Legislature will set the yields and base education tax rates to fund the voter-approved school budgets. It’s also crucial that we have an open discussion regarding what pushed our schools into the position of asking for such large increases. If we don’t then Town Meeting Day 2025 could look much like Town Meeting Day 2004.
It’s understood that Act 127 - which changed school funding to help those schools that have students more expensive to teach - is part of the problem. But by no means is it the sole culprit. There is the issue of health care costs, salary increases for teachers and staff, buildings falling apart out of neglect, and schools being forced to take on tasks far beyond what most of us consider a normal work day. There is the fact that Vermont has the lowest teacher/pupil ratio in the nation and that our per student costs are among the top nationally. We have too many small schools teaching too few students.
That is the school’s side of the ledger. As for the state and the tools it has to generate the necessary revenue, that includes the property tax, the sales and use tax, the purchase and use tax, the rooms and meals tax, money from the lottery and other sources like interest from the wind and solar fund.
But the heavy lifting - two-thirds of the total - comes from the property tax, homestead and non homestead. But the amount paid is also limited by one’s income instead of the value of the property. In fact, two-thirds of Vermont’s resident homeowners get an income-based adjustment, meaning there is a limit to the impact any school budget would have on the amount they pay. In 2023 that income limit - maximum household income - was $128,000.
One of the questions legislators must consider is reducing the maximum household income figure down to an amount that includes more taxpayers and generates enough additional money. They could also raise the sales tax, the rooms and meals tax, etc. They could also consider their proposed tax on the rich. They could also scuttle Act 127 and ask schools to retool their budgets, except there is little to no time left, and its demise would do little to change the tax rate.
There is another fear that accompanies how we pay for our schools; it’s the fear that taxpayers will be so spooked by school budgets that they say no to all other budgets, municipal and otherwise.
If ever there were a time to communicate with Vermont’s voters before Town Meeting Day, this would be it.
By Emerson Lynn
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here