“My concern is, as soon as we put ideas on the table, people might get nervous and concerned and afraid and step away.” Those were the words of House Speaker Jill Krowinski [D-Burlington] when asked what her strategy might include to address the cost of education in Vermont.
Her hesitancy has been echoed by Senate Pro Tempore Philip Baruth, and Gov. Phil Scott. All are reluctant to be specific about which path to pick to offer relief to the taxpayer. [They show the same hesitancy in addressing the state’s healthcare challenges.]
Ms. Krowinski is chair of the 13-member Commission of the Future of Public Education, which the Legislature established last session. Its task was to find ways to make the education system more affordable and equitable. The report is to be made public before the Legislature convenes in early January.
Don’t expect any revelatory proposals. As Rep. Peter Conlon [D-Cornwall], chair of the House Education Committee was quoted as saying, “What you’re going to see on that list is not a lot of new ideas. These are ideas that have been around for a long time.”
What Mr. Conlon is saying is that we know the problem, we’re just hesitant to act. Ms. Krowinski is saying the same thing, noting the obvious, the necessary changes will be painful to those communities directly affected.
The preliminary report contains only two ideas that would make much of a material difference. One was establishing how small a school could be and still be considered big enough to provide students a decent education. The other was another round of consolidations. Another option would be to increase the number of students per teacher. [Vermont has the nation’s lowest student-to-teacher ratio.]
The report also includes the potential strategy of mitigating costs by raising taxes on the state’s millionaires, which could net roughly $70 million. That won’t happen. The Democrats don’t have enough votes to override a promised veto. And while a rejiggering of how the property tax is calculated might make it easier to understand, it does nothing to lower costs.
The governor has proposed options, such as cutting the state’s universal school meals program, at a savings of $20 million annually, which is a pittance. There is also the possibility of using the state’s $47 million educational stabilization fund to buy down property tax rates. [The draw-down would be replenished through cuts to the system over a set number of years. This is only a temporary fix and a lousy one at that.]
With November’s rout of the Democrats, all parties are on the same page, preaching the same refrain, which is to hold taxpayers “harmless” this legislative session.
There is only one way to do that: Close the schools in Vermont that are too small to fulfill their missions. As Mr. Conlon says, this is an old idea whose suitability is becoming more and more obvious.
The governor is right when he says it’s going to be “difficult for all of us.” It’s also easy to understand Ms. Krowinski’s hesitation to even broach the idea for fear she will draw the wrath of those affected communities. Closing a school and busing students to a larger school nearby affects all concerned, and, yes, they will protest.
But our options have been exhausted. To continue as is means continued pressure on all Vermont’s taxpayers. It means placing an ever increasing burden on an educational system that will need to compete for fewer and fewer resources. That’s a lose-lose proposition. Being afraid to address what needs to be done is very simply a lack of leadership. What voters want is action. Not inaction.
By Emerson Lynn
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here