We ignore our long-term care needs in Vt. at our own peril

Posted

In 1935, President Franklin D. Roosevelt signed the Social Security Amendments into law. Thirty years later President Lyndon B. Johnson added Medicare and Medicaid. The three programs are the most enduring social programs we have and they have worked because more people paid in than received, which was a function of a robust birth rate and a life expectancy that hovered near the age of retirement.

That’s all changed. Our birth rate has plummeted and life expectancy is nearing 80 years of age. Now, we have fewer paying in and more receiving. With our drive to live longer, it’s expected that women will live to be 89 to 94 and men will live to be 83-86 by 2050.

Nice. And how are we supposed to pay for it?

Good question. We’re already seeing cracks in the system. Particularly in New England, home to the nation’s oldest states. Nursing homes are closing at a rate three times the national average, according to a just-released report from the Federal Reserve Bank of Boston. In every state in New England, including Vermont, the median nursing home is financially underwater, meaning we can expect more nursing homes to go out of business.

These pressures are particularly acute in Vermont, New Hampshire, and Maine, the states with the highest median ages. Vermont has the second highest “old-age dependency ratio” of 35.5 percent, which measures the number of people above retirement age against the number of people who are of working age [16-64.] 

That’s a huge number.

The reasons the long-term care industry is at risk are several: the reimbursement rates from Medicaid don’t meet the costs. The industry continues to struggle to meet its labor needs, and most people don’t have long-term coverage [two to three percent], often forcing the affected’s family to care for them [most often removing at least one family member from the workforce]

It’s an issue that also contributes to Vermont’s housing crisis. If the aged have no place to be cared for they stay in their homes, a practice likely to increase if long-term facilities continue to close and people continue to live longer. That practice will have an out-sized effect given the size of Vermont’s elderly population.

Dealing with this will be a challenge, but it’s also essential. We’re talking about more than the moral duty to care for the aged. We have a sizable number of hospital beds being occupied by patients who need to be in skilled care nursing homes, recuperating, not in hospital beds that can’t be used by patients, which increases wait times for the general population in need of a doctor’s care. And, as previously noted, it also takes able-bodied people out of the labor force and it compounds the shortage of available homes for sale.

We don’t focus on the elderly as much as we should, an oversight that speaks to society’s ageist biases. If not corrected it will be a costly mistake. The focus should shift from one focused on health, not longevity. We should address reimbursement rates that meet a nursing home’s costs so that the resident’s family can remain in the workplace and the pressure on our hospitals is reduced. And, we should be creative in building new manufactured housing communities that are affordable, close together, and, built around community. 

But perhaps what’s most important is just recognizing the challenge for what it is. That would be a refreshing start.

By Emerson Lynn

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here