Ways and Means puts growth, housing at risk

Posted

It’s happening again. We’re spending time and energy figuring out how NOT to do something that we all say is the most important thing Vermont needs to do. 

The need is more housing. It’s central to almost everything we agree is necessary to turn the state’s economy around and to make things affordable. Yet, every time we get close to doing something productive, actually building things, we have people who work to second-guess it and make it next to impossible to do. And, of course, there are those who do not want growth. At all.

That productive thing rational people are trying to do is embodied in S.127 which, among other things, expands the Tax Increment Financing [TIF] program in a way that makes housing development a possibility in Vermont’s smaller, more rural towns. The bill recognizes the success of the TIFs in St. Albans, South Burlington, Burlington, Montpelier, and Brattleboro, and wants the same potential available to the rest of Vermont.

What a thunderbolt of imagination and forethought. Small Vermont towns with new homes. Maybe even space for a new business. A new lifeline for schools struggling to keep the doors open. Dare to imagine.

The Senate agreed and passed the bill. And then came the breakdown. 

The House Committee on Ways and Means has taken the Senate-passed bill and essentially made it unworkable. As Gov. Phil Scott said, “it’s taking a step backwards.”

The Senate’s bill let municipalities borrow money for infrastructure needs, like roads, bridges, and sewer and water lines. The accompanying development - like housing - would generate the revenue to pay off the debt. Not complicated.

The Ways and Means Committee left its commonsense at the doorsteps and bought into the tired old argument that an expanded TIF program would subtract from the state’s Education Fund, so the committee imposed a $40 million annual limit on the amount of increment financing that could be proposed for housing. They also added a provision to test whether or not the projects would have occurred without the TIF money. [It’s called the “but-for” provision.] They included add ons, like floor-area minimums, where the developments could be located, and oversight considerations. The committee even went so far as to sunset Vermont’s existing TIF program in 2028, the very program used to model the TIF program for Vermont’s smaller municipalities, the very program that has brought so much growth to a number of Vermont’s communities. 

It’s hard to imagine a move the committee could have made that makes less sense or does more harm.  It’s 1960s thinking applied to today’s changed economy. It’s intellectually bankrupt.

Vermont is 40,000 housing units short of where it needs to be. If there is any iron-clad definition of demand, this would be it, and if the committee’s “but for” thinking were accurate, that the housing development would happen anyway due to huge market demand, then where is it? Where are the homes? How long do we have to wait? Is there not a cost for us to sit and wait for something that may never come?

It’s also plain dumb to suggest that the benefits of TIF developments cost more than they are worth. In St. Albans, for example, we’ve added roughly $100 million to the grand list, something that, over time strengthens the education fund, which helps all of Vermont. The same can be said for the state’s other large TIF projects. Over time, they will work to make Vermont more affordable. Why would legislators want to rob us of that advantage?

It also makes absolutely no sense to put a $40 million cap on the program. Why would legislators want to severely handicap a program that helps build what we need most, and in areas with little to no chance of attracting growth on their own? And, for those towns who think the Legislature’s action on education reform may end up closing their schools, wouldn’t it behoove them to support the Senate’s version of the bill so they might have a chance to attract the growth necessary to keep their schools open?

St. Albans City Manager Dominic Cloud testified this week before the Ways and Means Committee and delivered a message that should be understood by legislators who will vote on the bill’s final make-up: “Infrastructure is the business of government, not the private sector. We get our return from the new development, which allows a growing workforce, a growing student population, and a growing tax base. While the infrastructure is paid off in 20 or so years, the tax base, the housing and the workforce remain. But without the infrastructure, nothing happens and the erosion continues. The cost of doing nothing can be greater than the cost of the project.”

Not only does the Ways and Means Committee’s iteration of the bill have us doing nothing, it makes Vermont’s challenges even more difficult, which is almost impossible to do. 

As Miro Weinberger, former Mayor of Burlington and executive chair of Let’s Build Homes, warned: “It would be a breathtaking legislative failure” if the Legislature failed to get a bill passed that followed the Senate’s thinking.

Whatever passes the House will go to a conference committee with the Senate. Let’s hope our legislators recognize the backward thinking of the Ways and Means Committee and stay the course with the Senate’s version of the bill.

by Emerson Lynn

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here