Vt.'s Nikki Haley message

Posted

Vermont can take a moment’s pleasure in its vote for Nikki Haley and its opposition to Donald Trump on Town Meeting Day. With the help of some Democrats who crossed over to vote in the Republican presidential primary, Vermont will be the only state to deny Mr. Trump a clean sweep. It is a victory for moderation, if fleeting in duration and minuscule in impact. It helps set future stages. It says we are not a place where far-right extremism can find meaningful levels of support.

It was a vote of protest. All those who voted for Ms. Haley knew she had no path forward, but they could not vote for Mr. Trump, supporting his warped view of himself and the world. They could not countenance his narcissistic authoritarianism.

But those who voted for Ms. Haley woke up on Wednesday morning and put on their black armbands, a sign of their collective mourning. Ms. Haley dropped out, Mr. Trump will be the Republican nominee for president and President Joe Biden will be his Democratic challenger. Surely voters deserved better. In a country as blessed as ours, undeniably the world's most powerful economically and militarily, we could not find a better choice between an 81-year-old president who looks and acts his age and an ex-president who will be 78 in June and who can’t string together two sentences?

Clearly not.

We have Mr. Trump as a candidate because he left Washington in disgrace and sees his reelection as the only brush available to repaint his image in a more flattering light. He needs some “self-help” to deal with the 91 criminal charges he faces.

We have Mr. Biden because, like the bullied schoolyard kid, he can’t back down from Trump’s taunts.

One despises the other.

And America doesn’t want either.

Instead of championing the good of either candidate, we have Mr. Biden turning the State of the Union speech into one haymaker after another, trying to show Americans that he still has some juice in those 81-year-old veins. And we have Mr. Trump who posted a video pushing the idea that “God made Trump” because, according to the clip, “”I [god] need somebody willing to get up before dawn, fix this country, work all day, fight the Marxists, eat supper, then go to the Oval Office and stay past midnight at a meeting of the heads of state.”

And Vermont voters weren’t swayed? Little wonder Nikki Haley has her Vermont supporters. We have neither a fresh face nor new ideas to consider in November’s general election. And we have 70 percent of Americans who are unhappy with Mr. Biden’s presidency, a historic high. Yet, in Mr. Trump, we have a candidate whose favorability ratings are also in the dumpster.

In November, the voters who will decide this election are the ones who turned to Nikki Haley in Vermont. Both Trump and Biden have their partisans, voters who will walk on hot coals for their respective candidates. The remaining voters are the moderates among us, the independents who want change but have yet to be swayed by either candidate. The prevailing concern among these moderates/independents is that the remaining months of the race will continue to be dominated by the grievance-ridden diatribes of Mr. Trump and a continued shift toward the left by Mr. Biden. Both candidates are leery of moderating much of what they say for fear of alienating their bases.

What is dispiriting about our choice is that neither Mr. Biden nor Mr. Trump represents the talent and the dynamism that best describes the strength and the resources that are on display in our lives as Americans. Neither is the leader that satisfies the thirst most of us share for adaption in an ever-changing world.

In Vermont, that understanding gave rise to those who cast a vote for Ms. Haley. It should have surprised no one.

By Emerson Lynn

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here