When the Legislature created the Commission on the Future of Public Education, the assigned task was to determine how Vermont’s educational system could be made both sustainable and affordable. The report was delivered in December.
It didn’t happen.
No surprise.
The 13-member group, including key legislators, wasn’t about to make any solid recommendations before the Legislative session began. And the state’s school districts are in the last inning of putting together their budgets for the upcoming fiscal year. It’s too late for anything to be done that makes a meaningful difference in the short term.
November’s election, however, has removed any doubt that the cost of education will remain the Legislature’s key focus. The 14 percent property tax increase cost the Democrats their veto-proof majorities. It was an issue that acted as a proxy for all other affordability-related issues, including healthcare and housing. The impact is bleeding across the state, even challenging municipalities struggling to pass their budgets without sky-high municipal tax increases.
Democrats are keenly aware that their jobs may depend on adopting Gov. Phil Scott’s affordability agenda and figuring out how to get by on less.
If Vermont’s educational costs placed us in the nation’s middle, we’d have less to complain about. But they are not. As the commission’s report noted, we have the nation’s highest staff levels, the nation’s highest in terms of total dollars spent per pupil, and we rank 46th in the size of our schools. In the ten years between 2003-04 and 2022-23, we’ve also seen a 21.5 percent decline in our K-12 enrollment, a trend that continues.
As regards academic outcomes, our math scores are low and our reading scores, while above the national average, are in decline.
In short, our educational costs are increasing at the same time our academic results are in decline and our student count plummets.
That’s a problem.
The way forward isn’t complicated from a mathematical perspective: we need fewer schools and a teacher-pupil ratio closer to the national average. We need to set a base level for how small a school can be and still receive funding.
So whose ready for that discussion?
No one. That’s why we dance around the issue with suggestions that the rich be taxed enough to make up the difference, or that a foundation formula be set up that sets a per-school rate lower than what exists, but allowing school districts to vote to raise money locally [which is in direct opposition to the Supreme Court’s ruling in its 1997 Brigham decision.]
Another school-related expense that has not been addressed is the state’s $6 billion price tag on school construction. How is that to be addressed? If some of the state’s smallest schools also face not being able to open their doors because their buildings are not habitable, and because they can’t ask their taxpayers to foot the bill, is this how we cull the number of Vermont’s schools?
It’s easy to criticize the commission for its failure to detail how Vermont should deal with the sustainability and affordability of its schools. But in a way, it did. It pointed out the obvious, which is that we have a declining student population that has left us with too many schools, and too many teachers/staff for the few students we have.
This is not a problem we can grow our way out of. We have 80,000 students [down from over 105,000], who are divvied up between 288 public schools, 119 school districts, and 52 supervisory unions. That’s too few students for too many schools. Many of the schools on the smallest end are not able to deliver the quality education they deserve, despite the $25,253 check we write for each student.
In sum, we have a system that is neither sustainable, affordable, or even defensible. We all know this, including our legislators, and our governor.
So who is going to step forward and, as the taxpayers have asked, show the leadership necessary to begin the discussion?
By Emerson Lynn
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here