Vt leads nation in household income rise. And?

Posted

Things are good in Vermont. Better than in any other state, according to U.S. Census data just released. If the metric is median household income, we should feel twice as good as anyone else. From 2022 to 2023 Vermont’s median household income shot up 9.8 percent, the state's largest percentage increase in over a decade. Nationally, the increase was a shade over four percent.

We rock, right?

The data doesn’t come with an explanation. It could be that people are working more hours, or that more family members feel the need to get a job. It could be a good stock market run. Who knows? 

It was also noted, however, that, nationally, Vermont still ranks in the middle of the pack. Not surprisingly, it was also noted that the riches were not spread evenly. Chittenden County’s increase was 13.7 percent, far outpacing the rest of the state.

Shocker..

Still, it’s unlikely that Vermonters anywhere feel blessed by an unexpectedly large increase in their annual income. Last year was marked more by high inflation than anything else. And underlying it all is Vermont’s ranking as one of the five most expensive states to live in. [And that was before the state’s 14 percent increase in property taxes and our continuing rise in healthcare premiums.]

It is, after all, better to have a higher net income than it is to have a bump up in income that disappears after the bills are paid.

Still, it would be useful if the economists could explain why Vermont is such an outlier. The money has to come from somewhere. What can we expect going forward? 

It’s acknowledged that increased wages account for about half the increase. In 2023 employers were still struggling to fill their open jobs list, having to compete with other employers for the few workers available. That increase in wages - while a good thing - also placed pressure on businesses and raised the cost to the consumer. When, for example, hospitals were unable to find enough nurses they had to hire “travelers” which, according to Becker’s Hospital Review, costs double what a staff nurse costs in Vermont, a cost passed down to all Vermonters. In other words, we can’t assume that a 9.8 percent increase in our median household income means all boats have been lifted by the same tide of riches. They haven’t.

Whereas Chittenden County may be doing well, the rest of the state is not. Windsor County, for example, is expected to see a 41 percent decline in its workforce in the next decade. Orange County is in roughly the same boat, as are most of Vermont’s eastern and southern counties. A declining workforce subtracts considerably from the state’s future prosperity. Not only do these “at-risk communities” lose the local revenue, they have the same bills as the richer counties, which makes life doubly difficult.

The old saw is that you fish where the fish are, which is why Chittenden County’s numbers are so high. People move to where the services are.

Northwestern Vermont - Chittenden, Franklin, Grand Isle, and Lamoille counties - make up a little less than 40 percent of the state’s population but an overwhelming percentage of the state’s growth and economic strength. How does Vermont counter the trends that are so threatening to the rest of the state? How do we reverse the data that shows a continuing decline in students, fewer and fewer people in the workforce, an aging population, not enough housing, and a rising cost of living?

It will take more than a bump up in the state’s median household income, as nice as it is.

By Emerson Lynn

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here