Senate President Pro Tempore Phil Baruth (D/P-Chittenden) is in the last moments of his official political life, set to retire from a lengthy tenure in the Vermont Senate. He will leave with his last pitch being the “commonsense” need to ban guns in bars and restaurants that serve alcohol.
Mr. Baruth is almost certain to lose. Sadly. He’s got the governor against him, and even though the Senate may pass his bill, he is struggling to get the House to give the bill any serious consideration.
That’s unfortunate. The public’s safety is every legislator’s top responsibility. Ask the simple question: If you are in a bar or restaurant that serves alcohol, do you feel safe knowing everyone could be carrying a gun, or would you feel safer knowing no one would be carrying a gun?
Exactly. Almost all polls report the same reaction. And even deep red states like Texas, Kentucky, Idaho, and Louisiana have passed laws to prevent people from bringing guns into places where alcohol is served. So, Vermont can’t match the same gun safety standards as Texas?
Who are we?
Mr. Baruth was justified in his quote that “This is not some cockamamie liberal idea …there is no logical reason” that people should be allowed to bring a gun into a bar or restaurant that serves alcohol. Even gun owners strongly support banning guns in bars. Why? Because they are smart enough to know that drinking, guns, and rowdy crowds are a toxic brew.
Even for those legislators who are averse to any opposition on any issue, preferring always to sail on placid waters, there is little to no meaningful opposition when it comes to separating alcohol from guns in public places.
House Speaker Jill Krowinski (D-Burlington) has responded to Mr. Baruth’s overtures, saying, “It’s important to note that current law allows for owners of bars to ban a firearm on their premises.”
Really? So, it’s the responsibility of bar owners to frisk patrons to make sure they aren’t carrying guns? Are they the ones responsible for the public’s safety?
The critic’s response to the issue is one that embraces freedom, or the loss thereof. But no civilized society permits every freedom everywhere. We have laws that prohibit drunk driving, not because everyone who drinks and drives is reckless, but because one person’s recklessness can have such horrible repercussions. The same applies to guns and alcohol in bars and restaurants.
Those opposed to the legislation can’t hide behind the Second Amendment. Most gun owners know that owning a gun demands heightened responsibility. They are not absolutists. What would most of them say to legislators afraid to take up the issue?
“Grow a pair.”
Mr. Baruth might echo that.
By Emerson Lynn
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here