As the Vermont State College systems mulls its future, and spreading angst as it does so, the New York Times carried a story titled “Radical Survival Strategies for Struggling Colleges.” It noted that enrollment in the nation’s colleges was down 2.9 million from its peak in 2011 and 11 colleges a year are closing their doors, a number that is expected to rise to 15 in the near future. When the enrollment period ended last May, more than 400 colleges and universities were still begging for students. To those in higher education, the picture is terrifying.
Thus, it’s not a Vermont-only problem.
What seeped through the story was the difficulty of the challenge and to what extremes the higher ed community is stretching to find answers. Schools have done everything from slashing tuition to setting up special degree programs for the gambling industry to giving rebates to students who don’t graduate within four years. The people who are leading these revisioning efforts are seldom from the higher ed community; they are people skilled in the task of reimagining the colleges’ future. They are looking at the problem through the lens of an entrepreneur.
And, yes, running a college is a business. It eventually shuts its doors if there is no money to pay staff, or the rent. That’s happened three times in Vermont in the past 18 months. And three communities — and those students and staff — are the poorer for it.
But, unlike a business, moving forward with the VSC system means dealing with legislators — they appropriate what little money the system gets, the governor — who must take responsibility for whatever happens, the staff — which has a certain amount of political power, and the communities affected.
It’s particularly difficult to address without prompting the affected parties to be defensive. The question becomes, how do you have a serious conversation without creating fear, understanding that fear shuts the conversation down?
That’s the challenge Vermont faces on a number of fronts, education and health being the two most important.
By allowing the fear of change to prevail we put ourselves in the position of being reactive to the inevitable rather than proactive, being able to direct what we want to happen.
That’s the position we’re in with VSC. When the trustees and administrators traipse from one region to the other they hear the expected, which is that they want what they have, saying it’s more appropriate that the cuts, or changes, be made elsewhere. That happened in Lyndon and it happened in Rutland. It was made clear that all the fat in the system was in the system’s administration, no where else. In fact, things would improve if the staff were paid more, and if the student/teacher ratio were lower.
As if.
We should not expect otherwise. Expressions of self-interest are standard when people’s jobs are at risk. The same can be said of communities.
As a result, the VSC system will not announce any conclusive moves in early December as was expected. The problems have not disappeared, or gotten any better, but the choice has been made to move incrementally within the system that exists. No campuses will be closed.
That’s understandable. But it also highlights the weakness of the approach. Moving forward should not be the charge of Chancellor Jeb Spaulding, or his trustees, by their lonesomes. The debate needs to move beyond them and to the governor, the Legislature, and to the state’s 14 counties.
As the NYTimes article made clear, there are a number of options being explored by colleges and universities across the country. What needs to happen in Vermont is for the governor and the Legislature to appoint a commission whose job it is to figure out the options that may exist. Perhaps there should be a carrot dangled over the process; the promise of adequate resources once the path forward is agreed to.
Here’s what we can’t do: Wait.
by Emerson Lynn
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here