Vermont's tax balloon about to pop

Posted

The constant in Vermont’s Legislature is the need to do more, to meet the daily "asks" that come from constituents and special interests. Each ask is defensible. Each has its constituency. Each reflects a need. It’s when the asks are stitched together that things become unmanageable and unaffordable, the reality which, in the past, has prompted legislators to seek refuge within the body’s proposed budget. It’s how to say no, it’s how to explain that not all funding requests can be met.

That balance has typically been the product of a Legislature with sufficient numbers of both parties to force a compromise. That no longer exists. Together, the Democrats and Progressives have a veto-proof majority. They can do what they want, when they want, without Republican input, or fear of Gov. Phil Scott’s objection or veto. Whereas last year they were cautious about exercising this power, this session they are not.

The current proposal to raise somewhere between $163-$172 million in additional taxes speaks directly to that perception. Vermont’s needs - which include housing, the expansion of Medicaid, increased staffing for the judiciary, etc. - cannot be met within the governor’s proposed budget, according to the Legislature’s Democratic leadership. Thus, the Legislature is poised to raise taxes on Vermonters who earn more than $500,000 annually. It would also increase the property transfer tax for homes valued over $600,000 and increase taxes on Vermont’s corporations.

This comes at a time when Vermonters are about to be hit with a double-digit increase in their property taxes [an estimated $241 million statewide], and an $80 million hike in our payroll taxes to fund last year’s passage of legislation to strengthen the state’s childcare programs.

Nowhere has the debate within the Legislature included a discussion about doing more with less, striving to be more efficient, or rethinking the role of government. Instead, the preferred choice is to blow more air into the state’s budgetary balloon.

If the need to raise an extra $150 million or so was confined to a specific objective - like housing, for example - that would be one thing. It’s defensible to meet a short-term budget need with a short-term revenue source. It’s problematic when it’s a forever increase.

The impending double-digit property tax increase is forever. So is the payroll tax for childcare. And the proposed tax on the wealthy, the increased property transfer tax, and the hike for corporations. Vermont’s already a highly taxed state and an expensive one to live in. We’re about to become more so.

Vermonters in general are less concerned about the proposed tax on the wealthy than they are property tax increases because it affects a small percentage of the population. No one is worried about the “rich.” Besides, as we’re told by the proposal’s supporters, it’s a myth that raising taxes on the rich causes them to pick up and move to a more favorable environment. It’s easy money. Grab it. Don't look back.

But it’s also a myth that supporters of the proposal know the full ramifications of passing such a law. If passed, Vermont would have the highest corporate tax rate in the country and it would rank in the top two nationally for high-income individuals. That’s a powerful message and one that would be forever part of our identity, something easily researched by any company or individual considering Vermont as a place to live and work. There isn’t any way to calculate how many potential residents or businesses took a look at us and then decided to look elsewhere because they were put off by Vermont’s high tax structure [and that includes property tax levels as well.]

The argument is not how many high-income tax earners would leave Vermont for elsewhere [although it’s likely more than the proponents contend], the argument is how unattractive we make ourselves to those we’re trying to lure from elsewhere. Remember, as a state we’re losing population and getting older by the minute. Our success depends on attracting new people to Vermont, not just keeping the ones we have. To do that means being perceived as an affordable place to live.

We’re failing on that score and the pending legislation would only weaken Vermont’s ability to do better. The balloon is about to pop.

By Emerson Lynn

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here