Vermont has a drinking problem, why do we resist help?

Posted

They are the stories that break your heart. Stories with no answers, and few hidden blessings. An early, avoidable death. People who must fend for themselves in isolation. Broken families. Loves lost. Children forgotten. Careers shattered. Shame deep enough to swallow the fight to get better.

And the stories, they don’t go away. Or get better.

They are the stories of alcoholism and in Vermont, they are the stories of numbers that belie a state of our small size. According to a Seven Days story written by Colin Flanders, one out of every eight adult Vermonters has alcohol-use disorders, “defined as the inability to stop drinking despite negative consequences.” More than 10 percent of our male adult population has more than two drinks a day, with women averaging a drink a day. Over 61 percent of Vermont’s adults drink, compared to the national average of 50 percent.

And?

Who cares? What’s new about that?

Alcohol is the nation’s most popular drug. It’s the social lubricant that frees conversation and coaxes the timid to the dance floor. The use of alcohol is ubiquitous. And celebrated. Watch the movie [Anora] that dominated this year’s Oscar awards. Remove alcohol and you have no movie. The same applies to a majority of films. [And have you noticed that smoking is almost equally prevalent in cinema even though, as a habit, it’s fallen precipitously over the decades?]

We lost over 178,000 Americans in 2021, which was a 29 percent increase over the total four years prior, according to the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Yet, it’s popularity continues to soar because, among other things, we use it as a mechanism to sleep and to address all the other stresses is our lives. This, despite the fact that it’s bad for us [even red wine has lost its halo as being healthy.] We continue to imbibe because of habit and social approval. Food and drink are a cornerstone of how and why we socialize.

So, why the heartbreak?

Too many people use it to excess. Particularly in Vermont. Awareness of its impact is not what it should be. More people are hurt by its use than should be for a state our size.

One of the people profiled in Mr. Flanders story is Rep. Kate Nugent [D-South Burlington] who is pushing the idea of an excise tax on alcohol retailers and producers. A state tax on alcohol hasn’t been done since 1981 - 44 years ago. The objective is the same as it was with tobacco; the more it costs, the less it’s used. It worked with cigarettes, and it works with alcohol. Currently our tax rate puts us in the middle nationally. Ms. Nugent’s bill would raise the tax on a gallon of beer from 26 cents to $1.36, the tax on a gallon of wine would go up from 55 cents to $3.75 and the sales tax on hard liquor would be doubled to ten percent.

The proposed taxes would raise about $15 million, which, as the bill is written, would go to expand mental health efforts in Vermont’ schools, and to do more to support people with alcohol-use disorders.

The proposed taxes would not raise the cost of a drink to a level most consumers would notice, but opposition from the liquor industry is a given. Raise a tax once and it’s easier to raise it again. It’s a foot in the door. Something to stop.

Vermont has the same issue with tobacco. The state, along with most other states, settled its suit with the tobacco industry in 1998 and through a master settlement agreement has received almost $800 million since. The money has been used to recover health care costs associated with smoking-related illnesses and for campaigns to induce consumers to refrain from using tobacco. But it’s been a struggle and a less than optimal amount of money has actually been dedicated to mounting a sustained campaign against smoking. There was always the struggle between those managing the funds and legislators who wanted to use the money to balance the budget, or for other non-tobacco related needs. 

That, in part, is an issue with the proposed tax on liquor. If the misuse of alcohol is the problem it’s said to be - and we would think that’s accurate - then it’s crucial the money be spent to reduce usage.

Why? Because, like tobacco and obesity, the abuse of alcohol contributes to the high cost of health care in Vermont. It’s one of the reasons our healthcare premiums are double the national average. For every dollar spent on health care in Vermont 84 cents of it goes to treating chronic healthcare issues, which, by definition, is controllable. 

So, yes, the stories are heartbreaking. They also lead to the frustration that comes from doing nothing about it. Here is one small opportunity to guide us in a healthier direction. Raise the tax. Use the money to curb overuse. Build awareness. Join arms with the tobacco cessation folks in Vermont. Learn how to make a lasting difference that makes us healthier and costs us less.

by Emerson Lynn

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here