UVM and its $460,000 a day loss

Posted

A September 2024 report by the Oliver Wyman consultants painted a gloomy picture of the state’s healthcare system, predicting that if drastic changes were not made, the system would collapse and several hospitals would be forced to close their doors. The response to the report was largely disbelief. The healthcare industry makes up 20 percent of Vermont’s economic output; hospitals alone employ roughly 15,000 to 20,000 Vermonters. Surely they would prevail.

Survive? Probably. But they will be different.

A look at just how different was offered recently by UVM Health CEO Stephen Leffler, who told Vermont legislators last week that the University of Vermont Medical Center is losing $460,000 each day, or about $160,000,000 annually.

He said he was not surprised. UVMMC has been forced to reduce its insurance payments to Blue Cross Blue Shield of Vermont by 12 percent. Expenses continue to rise, and the state’s regulator, the Green Mountain Care Board, has capped the hospital’s ability to generate revenue.

The hospital must cut roughly $100 million a year for the next three years.

When the Oliver Wyman report was issued, few imagined that, two years later, we would be reading about UVMMC needing to cut $300 million from its operations, or that it would ever lose almost half a million dollars every day. UVM’s always had the political clout - and the administrative staff - to protect itself and to continue its growth. It has been the 800-pound gorilla that controlled the state’s healthcare system.

And grow it did. It absorbed the Central Vermont Medical Center in Berlin in 2011, expanded across Lake Champlain with the hospitals in Plattsburg and Elizabethtown in 2013, and in 2016-2017 continued its growth, adding the medical center in Malone, N.Y., and Porter Medical Center in Middlebury.

It was accomplished under the claim that the centralization of the hospital’s operations would save money and that the expansion of services would draw more patients. It was described as a win-win.

And, obviously, the larger the healthcare network became, the less the competition, and the greater the ability of the hospital to control its market.

Until it couldn’t.

The reckoning underway is one ultimately forced by the people asked to pay. All Vermonters. Health care premiums soared, and we quickly became known as the state with the nation’s highest health care costs. Twin that with the Green Mountain Care Board, whose job as regulator is to control the state’s health care costs.

Board chair Owen Foster was quoted as saying, “We have to get a grip on the cost of our care. We just have to, or the system’s not going to survive. Frankly, I think the system’s a little delayed in starting that earnest effort….This is the reckoning that we’ve all known was coming…No one wants to see a 10 or 20 percent commercial rate increase, right?”

Right.

Still, the challenges for Mr. Leffler are considerable. Last week, UVM met with its 3,000 support staff to begin negotiations for a new contract. Union leaders have called on legislators to pay for their increases by raising taxes on the wealthy.

Right. Not going to happen. Each dollar raised by such a tax has been spoken for a dozen times over, and its chances of being signed into law are nil. At the same time, every dollar that goes into a new contract has to be met with a dollar in savings.

Mr. Leffler has his work cut out for him. So does every hospital in the state.

UVM’s mistake is that it was never able to produce any economies of scale in its consolidations. The primary objective was to drive new business through the door. They sought to protect what they were building by adding new layers to the administrative/executive staff, something that is now being dismantled.

That was happening as Vermonters kept seeing their premiums soar to double the national average.

The power shift back to reality has been quick and effective. Control has shifted from the hospital network to the GMCB, and the tool being used is limiting the revenue a hospital can generate, forcing the hospital to meet its target by limiting its expenses.

And that’s where UVM finds itself. It has to find $100 million in savings each year for the next three years.

Mr. Leffler has agreed that the changes need to be made, but he wants to do it “without breaking things,” something he says means negotiating a “tight balance.”

It’s understood that his task is a difficult one, but, after all, Vermonters have been managing that “tight balance” for years.

By Emerson Lynn

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here