Using Bernie's voice

Posted

“I just do not feel there is a sense of urgency.”

The words come from Sen. Bernie Sanders and the sentiment is one embraced by most Vermonters when it comes to the state’s health care system: it’s crushingly expensive, accessibility is poor, and health care outcomes are less than they should be.

Mr. Sanders’ words carry some weight. He’s chair of the Committee on Health, Education, Labor and Pensions and he is upset that his own state - long defined as one of the nation’s healthiest - is now being seen as home to one of the unhealthiest healthcare systems when it comes to affordability.

His frustration prompted him to summon the state’s top healthcare providers for a meeting Friday. Vermont’s senior senator told the providers that Vermonters, including the state’s businesses could not “afford large rate increases” and “we want to understand what’s going on and what we can do about it.”

The impetus for Mr. Sanders' visit was the recent filing by BlueCrosBlueShield and MVP for their 19 percent and nine percent rate increase proposals respectively to the Green Mountain Care Board. Owen Foster, chair of the Green Mountain Care Board, made clear his feelings: “Health care costs are rising faster than nearly anywhere in the country. Meanwhile, access is down and health outcomes have not improved…So we’re spending more and more, and asking Vermonters to pay more, and we’re not seeing the outcomes we want from that investment.”

Don George, CEO of BCBS of Vermont, blamed the problem on “deterioration of the health status” of his 200,000 BCBS clients, saying they were older, sicker, and more expensive to treat.

Steve Leffler, president and CEO of the University of Vermont Medical Center, was quoted as saying: “We need more younger Vermonters who need less health care, are not on meds, don’t have chronic illnesses. We’re seeing and feeling that every day.”

To almost every explanation Mr. Sanders’ response was, well, okay, so what are we doing about it?

There is no single answer to Mr. Sanders' question, but the senator is correct in showing his impatience, something that’s shared by most Vermonters. The health care system we have is not affordable for most and when people opt out of the system, the care they defer makes things more expensive later.

While there is no single answer to Mr. Sanders' question there are certain objectives that should be agreed to as essential steps forward, objectives Mr. Sanders could push. 

The first is to strongly encourage insurers to shift away from fee-for-service payments and accept captitated payments instead. Could the GMCB not push the state’s two insurers [and health care providers] into such an arrangement? Otherwise, if the only thing the providers have to do is raise their rates, how does the incentive change?

Second, is recognizing the futility of our circumstance if we do not figure out how to address a population that, as Mr. George and Mr. Leffler acknowledge, is growing sicker and whose medical conditions are increasingly complicated and expensive. To do so, however, will take time and a meaningful shift in resources to our primary care system. The only way to reduce our costs over time is to reduce the number of people in need of care and the only way to reduce the number of people who need care is to focus on making them healthier, earlier.

It was in 2018 that RiseVt did a first-of-its-kind study to measure the body mass index of every first, third, and fifth grader in Franklin and Grand Isle County. The result showed that 41 percent of those young students were either overweight or obese. According to the experts, there is no reason to believe that number isn’t reflective of Vermont in general, which means we have a train wreck heading our way. Eighty-four cents out of every healthcare dollar spent goes to chronic care issues, of which obesity is the largest contributor. We are about to be overwhelmed by tomorrow's generation's needs.

RiseVt, the health care prevention program operated through Northwestern Medical Center, is no longer in business. As the refrain goes, the money in health care is in sickness, not prevention. 

Which gets us back to the obvious. Labor is the major driver of expense for all healthcare providers. If a sicker and sicker population forces providers to continue their hiring spree then we can’t expect prices to decline.

The only way to force the necessary efficiencies is to change how we pay for our health care, which means no longer using fee-for-service payments and instead paying providers a set fee for a set service [this includes hospitals and insurers] and embracing an all-inclusive effort to address the need for preventative care, bringing back the RiseVT model, or something similar, statewide.

Mr. Sanders is in a unique position to help us get from here to there. Instead of following an example of what not to do, with our current system, he should be using his voice and his impatience to force us to go where we need to go. Push for the capitated payment system help us revitalize our efforts to become healthier.

That's the "urgency" we need.

By Emerson Lynn

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here