Two days a week?

Posted

The Champlain Valley Superintendents Association Wednesday announced all 16 of its school districts would begin the school year with a hybrid model, one in which students will attend in-school sessions twice a week and learn remotely three days a week.

The decision covers all 16 school districts in Franklin, Grand Isle, Chittenden and Addison Counties and it provides a 100 percent remote learning option for families who have no interest in sending their children to school.

No matter the association’s decision, it would be opposed by parents who hoped school administrators would have decided differently. No proposal would have been met with unanimity.

Still, it was not the decision expected given the fact that Vermont has the lowest number of new Covid-19 cases and a death rate that hasn’t moved in weeks. It’s not good news for parents who will now wonder how they can manage a job and be responsible for their children doing their five-hours a day screen time. It’s not good for businesses struggling to regain productivity. It’s not good for students who don’t have access to computers, and who don’t have home environments suitable for remote learning.

But this is not a choice school administrators made on their own. They are following a 25-page playbook put out by the state’s health department and the Agency of Education. Schools cannot meet the state’s guidelines and operate schools in their traditional fashion. The social distancing requirement alone precludes classrooms being conducted normally. There isn’t the space. And that’s just for starters.

The immediate question is one of duration. How long? Is this what we can expect until a vaccine is proven safe, effective and is available? If so, that’s a full year. Perhaps longer.

If Vermont’s case load remains close to current levels then that’s unacceptable. Parents can’t be put in that position. Neither can businesses. Nor can our children.

The Scott administration is doing to the school system what it did with the economy after the worst of the pandemic, which is to open the spigot a quarter turn at a time. Opening our schools at a “Class ll” level is that quarter turn.

Here’s what we need: A governor who tells us what standards we need to meet for schools to fully reopen. We’re Class ll now. If present standards are maintained for a month or two, can parents plan on their students returning to school full time by the end of October? November? What are the numbers we have to meet to be in Class lll, the least restrictive?

That standard should be set now so that the debate is less political later. We can’t be teased into further delays because things are “fluid” and no one is quite sure what’s on the horizon. There is no such thing as absolutes in this game.

As we look forward we should also separate preK-8 from high school. Virtually all studies show students in the younger grades don’t fall prey to the virus anywhere close to the levels of older people. Nor do they pass it on at similar levels as those older. Yet these are the kids most negatively affected by remote learning requirements.

For students who don’t have access to a computer, and who don’t have suitable home situations, we need to do better than what’s being proposed. Schools are to be open five days a week; it’s the classes that are being divided into two groups, with Wednesday being a cleaning day. For those disadvantaged, space needs to be found for them. They’ve already lost a third of last year’s learning, that can’t be compounded by the loss of substantially more time.

by Emerson Lynn

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here