When President Donald Trump announced plans to force hospitals and insurance companies to disclose the actual prices they charge, a tremor shot through the health care industry, and the world of Democratic politics. The president was not only forcing transparency on highly opaque industries, he’s also neutralizing the Democrats in their move to Medicare for all.
His proposed rule changes can be accomplished through executive order and do not require the approval of Congress; the affected industries’ only recourse would be to challenge him in court, which is assured.
The proposed rule changes would force hospitals to report what they actually charge insurance companies, and hospitals would be required to create a specific price list for roughly 300 of the most common procedures, the purpose being to allow customers to shop around for the lowest price. Insurance companies would have to make public the prices they are charged for services, prices that reflect their negotiated discounts.
The administration is taking aim at an industry that is increasingly concentrated and monopolistic in structure, a practice that has become more intense with the hospitals’ purchase of doctors’ practices. Hospitals, with their attendant physicians and other services, constitute over 50 percent of the health care industry’s tab, according to the administration. Big Pharma, accounts for about 15 percent of the costs.
From a purely political perspective, it’s easy to see how the president stands toe-to-toe with the contenders in the Democratic primary. They both have villains to attack, they both share the same promises, which is lower costs and improved access. To the average consumer, there is little that separates, except for the plan being offered by Vermont’s Bernie Sanders, which, from the outset, would force people off their present plans.
Of the two, it’s easier to see how the president’s plan prevails. If he can impose the changes through executive order and not require the approval of Congress, then, court challenges notwithstanding, his is the quicker path.
Even the president’s sharpest critics have to give him credit for challenging an industry that other presidents did not. But what’s instructive in the debate is to examine the sought after outcomes and compare them to what Vermont has and what Vermont is doing with its all payer reform model.
The president is asking for transparency in pricing for both hospitals and insurance companies. Vermont is the only state with a board whose responsibility it is to examine the budgets of both groups and to approve price requests for both. Transparency is required. Our increases are considerably below the national average.
Both the president and those Democrats vying for the nomination are pushing against hospital monopolies and the perceived lack of competition that is forcing prices skyward.
But how better to deal with monopolistic practices than to pay hospitals a set amount determined by the number of people in a market? This is the “capitated” system Vermont’s pursuing with its all payer model run by OneCare, the accountable care organization in charge of its implementation.
There are also several key challenges both sides of the political aisle face that Vermont doesn’t if the all payer model is pushed to its potential. The objective of the president’s plan — ratcheting prices down through transparency — could be derailed by having the lower priced hospitals raising their prices upward, rather than the high cost hospitals lowering theirs. His efforts could also be nixed in court. The proposed “Medicare for all” is the heaviest of all political lifts. Health care is almost 18 percent of the nation’s economy, turning it upside down isn’t going to happen any time soon, no matter who is elected president, even if the Democrats manage to take control of the Senate and the House.
Meanwhile, Vermont’s experiment with true health care reform, focused on cost controls and health care outcomes, is in process. As a state, we’re further along the reform path than any other state.
There is more to accomplish; the idea of full transparency is something that should be pushed regardless of the approach. Patients should know in advance what their insurer will pay for whatever procedure is recommended. Period. If what an insurer pays for a mammogram varies considerably from hospital to hospital, patients should have the right to make an educated choice.
That’s the power of the marketplace. That’s what can happen if outcomes are the means by which the consumer can make an educated choice. If hospitals — and insurers — are put in a position whereby compensation improves as does the health of the population, then we’re focused on what matters most.
How long it takes to get there is anyone’s guess, but the president’s decision to push forward [assuming he doesn’t recant as he did with the ban on flavored vaping] in the battle to force transparency in hospital and insurance industry pricing is encouraging.
by Emerson Lynn
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here