Trump should pressure Russia, not just Ukraine

Posted

When Russia invaded Ukraine four years ago, the overwhelming consensus was that the war would be a short one. Brutal, of course. But short. We watched transfixed as the two forces clashed and the murderous toll began its climb skyward. How would Ukraine endure?

Almost as soon as Russia began the war, there were efforts to stop it, but to no avail. Russian President Vladimir Putin sought to expand Russia’s footprint and believed it would be a skirmish that would yield his sought-after goals. Time was on his side. He had no reason to compromise. He still doesn’t.

The war in Ukraine does not command the same level of attention it did four years ago. It’s fallen from our screens as other crises take its place, like Gaza or the government shutdown. When it did cross our minds, it was always an issue of wonder. How could such a small nation hold on for such a long time, suffering countless deaths and watching as parts of their nation were reduced to rubble?

Fresh off his peacekeeping victory in Gaza, President Trump set loose his negotiators to see if Ukraine’s weakened position on the battlefield, and an internal scandal, had made President Volodymyr Zelensy more open to a new round of negotiations. Thinking it had, the president’s team drew up a 28-point plan [with aid from Russia] that would end the war. The problem was that it required  Ukraine to give up everything it had fought for. It was a plan written by Mr. Putin, a gift to himself. It sparked immediate and complete opposition from most NATO countries. Mr. Trump was forced to say it wasn’t his last offer, but it set up the unavoidable question: No one wants the war to end more than Ukrainians, but what sort of peace agreement could be drafted that would allow Ukraine to keep its sovereignty and  be able to defend itself? And even though the Russians have suffered a thousand-fold more than anyone could have predicted, what convinces Mr. Putin that he’s better off ending the hostilities? 

For starters, more pressure from the West. Taking all Russia’s $300 billion that has been frozen in Western accounts and putting it in a fund that will ultimately be used for its rebuilding, or for long-range missiles that can reach inside Russia. Ramped up pressure on Russia’s oil and gas exports. 

For Ukraine to concede any territory, or to agree to any weakened condition [like agreeing to reduce by a third the number of people in its army], it would need security guarantees that are absolute and not pieces of paper that Putin would tear up in little bitty pieces. 

The point is that it’s wrong for Mr. Trump to be applying all the pressure on Ukraine. The war has been almost equally brutal on Russia, and its economy is in tatters. Why not tighten the screws on Russia’s economy through its oil and gas exports? 

It’s also important for Mr. Trump to realise that a “victory” is not defined as having both sides hold their gunfire for a week or two, or six months. Real peace is only achieved if the conditions negotiated create an environment open to constant interpretation, with both sides understanding that the price of betrayal is more than either would like to chance.

If we fail, if the seeds of any negotiated peace are grounded in deceit, then we only guarantee ourselves that future wars are assured. That understanding is what Mr. Trump’s negotiating team should embrace as the negotiations proceed. This is not another audition for the Nobel Peace Prize. If Mr. Trump is truly interested in stopping the war and ending the bloodshed, then he will need to be more serious with his friend in the Kremlin.

By Emerson Lynn

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here