Town of St. Albans continues stormwater talks;; Selectboard pushes for pull back on budget

Posted

ST. ALBANS TOWN — The St. Albans Town stormwater discussion continues.

After roughly two hours of conversation Monday, the Town of St. Albans Selectboard isn’t entirely sure about its stormwater approach as the town adminstration tackles flooding issues affecting residents on the southeast side of town.

But they did find some consensus.

“We have everything in place. We have documents in place. We’ve got projects in place,”  selectboard member Jeff Sanders said. ”We need [the State of Vermont’s] money.”

This isn’t the first time the selectboard has stretched the clock talking about the town’s stormwater obligations. During Vermont’s historic flood this past summer, residents located near Interstate 89 found basements and lawns flooded with brown water after culverts and ditches in the area overflowed.

Since that time, stormwater infrastructure has been a consistent subject of discussion, driving hours of back-and-forth between the five selectboard members as they try to solve the problems caused by the flooding.

Compounding the problem are additional directives from the State of Vermont mandating that the town reduce the amount of phosphorus heading into Lake Champlain – in an effort to mitigate algae blooms – by slowing down water flows. 

Combatting both issues though costs money, as the town would need funds to move forward with major stormwater infrastructure builds. Subsequently, most of the selectboard’s discussions have focused on exactly where they expect to find the dollars.

Finding funds

Monday night’s discussion began with the proposal for a new program by public works director Dave Allerton. He said a few residents – no more than 10 – had asked that the town unclog ditches and culverts impeding water flows and causing some backup flooding. 

The town selectboard, however, had some concerns about the best approach. 

Private homeowners are responsible to keep stormwater infrastructure on their land outside of public right-of-ways clear of debris, but build-up over years has made the cost detrimental to some homeowners, especially for those physically incapable of doing annual maintenance. Through the proposed program though, they would be able to access public resources to complete the work. 

Selectboard member Jeff Sanders opposed the idea, as he said it came down to who was responsible for the work. Basically, if a property owner is at fault for neglecting their duties, why should the taxes of their neighbors be used to do the work?

“At what point does it flip from being a private matter to being a public matter?“ Sanders asked.

The board also asked how many homeowners would be interested in using the program. Allerton said he knew of a limited number primarily located near Interstate 89, but there could be more they don’t know about who could overburden the program.

Selectboard member Brendan Deso recommended that the board formalize the process to remove those risks. He suggests creating a grant program allowing residents to apply for the work to help cover costs. 

As selectboard members further discussed the issue, they realized that much of the conversation floated around the same thorny topics posed by the overall stormwater problem that the town faces – should the town use a pool of funds collected from everyone to benefit just a few people?

After another hour discussing the issue, selectboard members agreed they could at least lower its stormwater fees to make the town’s approach to its stormwater goals more equitable. No official motion, however, was passed either on the new proposed program or stormwater fees.

Lowering fees

Back in late August, the selectboard had motioned to nix its stormwater fees completely, but the vote was technically non-binding due to procedural issues. As the board revisits the topic, its members all said they were leaning toward repeating the effort, but they’d still have to find the money needed to pay for construction costs.

Sanders suggested using local option tax dollars instead of stormwater fees. In comparison to charging property owners, Sanders said LOT dollars are essentially “faceless” because they’re collected with purchases, which makes them more equitable across the board for taxpayers.

In comparison, hitting property owners with a fee, he argued, unfairly double charges those residents who have already sunk dollars into installing stormwater improvements on their property. 

Deso pushed back against the proposal. While he agreed the town should look at lowering stormwater fees, he argued that LOT funds will have limited stormwater use over the next few years as the town pursues additional building projects, such as a new fire station, improvements in the bay area and updates to St. Albans Bay’s Stone House. 

Nixing stormwater fees now, he said, would put the town in a difficult situation come budget season. In response, Sanders said that’s exactly what he’d like to see. 

“I want to force us to have to do that,” Sanders said. “I want us to have to take a hard look at that budget which is just building money every year and have to say no to something.” 

After the last budget’s year-over-year increase of 9 cents per $100 valuation, he said he’d like the town to put some serious thought into the hard decisions needed to keep the tax rate low for residents upset at their tax bills, including a re-examination of the stormwater fee.

Selectboard Chair Bryan DesLauriers and board member Jonathan Giroux both agreed with lowering the stormwater fees as well. 

In the case of a new fire station, Giroux said it could even be a matter of waiting a few years before going forward with any major buildouts, and in the meantime, he requested more information about the impacts of potential budgetary changes if the town does move forward with lowering fees.

“I think our ultimate goal is to lower the household rate and lower the business rate. So I guess if we did, we got to look at what our liabilities are currently, and what we need to fund them and what we don’t need to fund them,” he said. “I think we need a starting place, and we can build off that starting place.”

The other approach, pushed by Deso, was making a stronger organized appeal to the State of Vermont to help pay for the town’s stormwater projects. 

If the town could join together with other municipalities hampered by the state’s obligation to clean up the lake, then they’d have a better chance proving to the state that it needs to provide funding. Until that time, Deso recommended re-examining what stormwater projects the town moves forward with.

Allerton said he has been talking to other public works departments to gauge what other municipalities are doing to complete the state’s goals, and he agreed he would broach the topic with the City of Burlington to see if they’d be interested in making the appeal to the state together. Until then, the discussion continues.

“We’re funding our town resources, our town staff, to actually get all these things done that’s mandated to us by the state and EPA. But I think for going forward, we’re trying to look at, what would it look like if we did this or that?” DesLauriers said.

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here