To our neighbors to the North: patience

Posted

Nowhere in Vermont is the relationship between Canada better understood or deeply felt than the line of towns running from Alburgh to Canaan, including the Franklin County towns of Swanton, Franklin, Berkshire, and Richford. And it’s been ages - if ever - that the Vermonters who live in these border towns, and the Quebecers who live a stone’s throw away, have been so conflicted.

A lengthy investigation of the relationship was the subject of a report in Politico last Friday. Political is a worldwide digital publication that focuses primarily on political matters. The point of the story was to explain how a surge in illegal entries in 2024 contributed to these towns’ support of President Donald Trump, and how Mr. Trump’s election continues to have consequences few considered.

It was understood - particularly by those who lived along the border - that the immigration issue was out of control. Nearly 20,000 people crossed through the Swanton Sector in 2024, which “obliterated records of the rate sector for the previous 17 years combined.” And it was agreed by both the United States and Canada that the surge could be attributed to “transnational criminal organizations operating in both nations.”

It was enough to flip every town along the Canadian border to Mr. Trump’s camp, which was the first time since Ronald Reagan’s 49-state sweep in 1984. People wanted the wave of illegal migrants to be stopped. They were fearful of the hordes traipsing through their backyards.

And President Trump has delivered. The number of those crossing the border has been drastically reduced. People along the border feel safer. It’s become the “unlikely and inevitable frontline for Trump’s signature politics,” according to the article.

If the “success” were confined to restricting the criminal element, few would complain. But, as the article detailed, the collateral damage has been beyond what anyone would have guessed. Vermont’s dairy farmers are dependent on migrant workers. They can’t get their product to market without them. As farmers in the article explained, our workers have no interest in those jobs. We have a shortage of young workers as it is.

The president’s onslaught has pushed the migrant workers we have into hiding. Who could blame them? If you were in their position, would you travel without concern and speak to strangers? Not unless you didn’t care to which country might be your next home, and which prison might serve your next meal.

Equally complicated is the President’s move to slap tariffs on many Canadian products, and how he has changed the friendly nature of Canada’s relationship with us to one that is untrusting and resentful.

The effects are dramatic. Tourism levels have been cut by a third. Prices have gone up. The Quebec government announced recently that the money dedicated to finishing the last leg of Autoroute 35 to the Highgate border will be spent elsewhere. That’s not a small thing. Vermont has been hoping for that connection for decades. It was considered a primary tributary from “greater Montreal’s” 4.4 million population to Vermont.

How do you make up for that?

As the Politico story details, even the people in southern Quebec are skeptical about traveling across the border as they have in the past.

So what’s our hope? First and foremost, it would be agreeing to find a way to give our undocumented workers a way to stay here legally. But we have an administration that is focused almost exclusively on exporting them. There seems to be little hope that the president will change his priorities anytime soon. But the law needs to be changed.

And what about our souring relationship with our neighbors to the north? Good luck. As beneficial as it would be there is little evidence that our circumstances rate very high with the person sitting in the Oval Office.

So, in a word: patience. We have to believe that the good nature of our relationship will return.

By Emerson Lynn

 

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here