This is Vt.'s Manhattan Project

Posted

The Wall Street Journal Monday told the story of a secret group of the nation’s top scientists, interested billionaires and industry leaders who have banded together, in a Manhattan Project-like venture, to find answers to the coronavirus pandemic. It’s a combination of the nation’s best minds, the wealth to fund the group’s needs, and the power to make the necessary political connections. It’s also politically agnostic and financial gains from the efforts cannot accrue to the people involved. According to the Journal’s reporting, the group has, and continues to have a considerable impact on the ideas generated, the ones weeded out, and the need to cut through the red tape. It’s altruism at its finest. The best minds matched against a seemingly intractable problem.

Why could Vermont not marshal the same efforts as it begins to reimagine the Vermont State College System, and higher education in general?

The idea is offered because it’s almost a given that the creativity and the boldness necessary to make a meaningful and sustainable change can’t be generated through the VSC’s Board of Trustees, or though whomever is appointed to replace outgoing Chancellor Jeb Spaulding.

That is not a criticism of the board’s members or Mr. Spaulding. The colleges’ governance system isn’t set up to be anything more than a way to protect the status quo. It can’t be otherwise considering the board’s make-up, which, of the 15-members includes four legislators, five gubernatorial appointees, four members who are board-elected, a single student representative and the governor who is an ex officio board member.

Why, at this crux moment, would we expect them to steer the college from the abyss and on to greener pastures? Is it likely they know something Mr. Spaulding didn’t? Did the board have a surer path forward?

They did not. Certainly nothing that was made public.

It’s also misguided to think a new chancellor, or even a new group of trustees will fare any better if the thinking isn’t expanded far beyond what the system and its political limitations allow. It’s a touch more complicated than asking the Legislature to give the system the money it thinks its needs.

It’s not even a sure thing the best answers can be found within Vermont. [We have a tendency to follow the 90-10 rule in which 90 percent of the work is done by the same 10 percent of the people, which limits the imagination.] But it’s not difficult to find the talent willing to help, and it’s not difficult to find people in other states, or countries, who have had similar experiences and who have discovered creative alternatives. Vermont is a small state with a handful of college campuses, it wouldn’t take a group of skilled educators/administrators long to put together various plans for the state to consider. This outside group would also have the advantage of not been hemmed in by the politics that essentially doomed the tenure of Mr. Spaulding.

In fact, that would be one of the guidances offered to the outside group of consultants: Give us ideas as to what would work, and why, without regard to the ideas’ political suitability.

How Vermont’s higher ed community manages through its current day crisis [ignoring for the moment the potentially calamitous effect of the pandemic] will be essential to the state’s social and economic future. A challenge that significant requires us to set aside our provincialism and to find and then ask the best minds we can find to help.

This is Vermont’s Manhattan Project.

by Emerson Lynn

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here