This is Gov’s ‘common sense?’

Posted

Gov. Phil Scott Wednesday vetoed legislation to ban the sale of flavored tobacco and vaping products, which was not a shock. He had signaled his concern about the bill’s future when it passed both the Senate and House. The proposed legislation would cost the state’s treasury between $7 million and $15 million, something he characterized as “poor timing” considering the state’s tight financial picture.

But, it was not the loss of tax revenue that ultimately pushed the governor to veto the bill. Or so he said. It was the “hypocritical” nature of the bill. How, he asked, can the state ban flavored tobacco and vaping products when it allows flavored alcohol and cannabis products?

In a letter to legislators, he wrote: “..we (the state) allow, and in fact actively advertise and profit from, the sale of flavored alcohol products. We also promote and highlight our distilleries and breweries with all their unique flavors, which has been incredibly successful, not only financially, but also from a branding and tourism standpoint. But it can’t be denied alcohol abuse has been the root cause of many societal challenges…I’ve found people lose faith in government when policies have these types of inconsistencies because they contradict common sense.”

The governor’s reasoning is wrong on all accounts. People lose faith in the government when it fails to protect people’s health. People lose faith in government when it foregoes common sense and picks profits over the essential need to fight addictive behaviors that place our youth at risk.

There is also no feasible way to meet the governor’s concerns about hypocrisy, and he knows that. Would he have signed the bill if it had banned flavored alcohol and cannabis products? Of course not. And, by the way, the public health community - writ large - would be only too happy to push such legislation. Would the governor lead such an effort? Would he stand up and call for legislators to rework the bill so that it would include flavored alcohol and cannabis products?

Not a chance.

The governor was also wrong when he talked about the “silence” over flavored cannabis products. The medical profession was strongly opposed to the legislation that has given us the cannabis industry we now have.

That's what should be our collective concern. Despite the fact that 75 percent of all Vermonters favored the ban on flavored tobacco/vaping products, and despite the fact the entire medical community actively pushed for the legislation’s approval, we have nothing to show for it. Despite the public’s will, and the Legislature's strong approval, the governor said no.

So who won and why?

It was neatly summed by the CEO of the Northeast Wholesalers Association: “Just as he [Gov. Scott] promised in his first inaugural address, the governor viewed this legislation through the lens of those it would have most impacted - Vermont’s small businesses.”

There you go. It's about the money.

The House and Senate do not have votes to override the governor’s veto unless some minds are changed. But the effort should be made nonetheless. Perhaps in the interim, it will be realized that improving the public’s health - at all ages - is a better bet for the economy and our well-being than the fractional benefit gained by those who sell flavored tobacco and vaping products.

That’s the common sense Vermonters are looking for in their leadership.

By Emerson Lynn

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here