The unavoidable debate about our schools

Posted

Vermont would need to spend a minimum of $6.4 billion over the next two decades to catch up with the deferred maintenance of our schools, according to a report released earlier this year. That is not going to happen. We don’t have that kind of money.

There are two reasons the bill is as high as it is. First, is the fact that we have 384 school buildings, a disproportionate number for a state as small as Vermont. Second, is the Legislature’s decision in 2008 to get out of the school construction aid business, leaving all construction needs to local school districts to finance. [The state used to fund 30 percent of the cost of approved school construction projects.]

Two additional reasons complicate the challenge even further. The first is our continuing demographic decline. Vermont is slated to keep losing students for another 15 years. The second is the Legislature’s decision this past session to reimpose an “excess spending” penalty. Schools that spend over 118 percent of the state’s per-pupil spending average are penalized. Each dollar over the amount is taxed as if it were two dollars. The per-pupil average includes any money intended for school construction.

Because school construction costs are so pricey, the excess spending penalty effectively shuts down most school districts’ ability to handle their construction needs. If the existing policies remain in place we will continue to watch as many of our schools continue to age, making the teaching environment all the more difficult and the buildings less safe to occupy.

For many of our schools, this is a crisis. The report also identified schools that needed fixing now, this year, to the tune of roughly $250 million. It further identified schools that need roughly $500 million in repairs within the next five years.

Where is that sort of money to be found?

While these needs continue to simmer in the background, we are consumed by the fight on the political front. The fury continues over the 14 percent increase slapped on Vermonters’ property tax bills this year. The appetite for additional increases to fund our schools is nil. 

But can we realistically expect our property tax bills to decline, or to even remain below the cost of inflation when healthcare costs continue to soar and the schools’ labor contracts have built-in step increases? It’s also a given that as we lose students through 2040 the cost per pupil in our public schools will also rise.

We have received two reports this year on key parts of the economy; one on schools and one on our hospitals. The common denominator to both was the recognition that there is an optimum size for both and to operate at a level below that is expensive. The choice to do so also lends itself to sub-par performances; it costs more to run the schools and students aren’t afforded the same educational opportunities given to students in larger schools.

Dealing with these challenges is anything but easy. It strikes at the heart of our rural character, which is the preference for smaller versus larger. And there are those among us who will fight tooth and nail to keep things exactly as they are. No matter the cost.

But the way out for our schools, particularly the smallest and the ones in greatest need of repair, seems almost beyond reach under current guidelines. If the state stays out of the school construction business and the excess spending penalty remains, these schools will continue to be less safe places to receive an education and more expensive to fix.

It’s almost impossible - if we are reasonable -to escape the necessary debate, which is to determine levels at which spending the public’s money on schools makes sense. We need to admit the obvious, which is that it’s better for Vermont to have an affordable, high-quality educational system [with fewer schools] than it is to have a more expensive, lower-quality educational system, with the same number of schools, just because it’s always been that way.

By Emerson Lynn

 

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here