The struggle for Vt to find a BETTER path

Posted

In Gov. Phil Scott’s State of the State address last week there was a single word in the 4,500-word address that was in all caps. It was the word BETTER and it was used to describe the advantages held by northwestern Vermont, specifically Chittenden and Franklin counties. We are where the money is, where people decide to live, where housing prices are up, jobs are plentiful and poverty less prevalent.

Meanwhile, as the governor notes, the rest of Vermont is less fortunate and obligated to put up the tax revenue to support our two counties. The governor’s point is that we need to spread the prosperity.

The governor’s observation is understandable. He’s elected by the people and there are more voters in Vermont outside our two counties than in. The stronger the state’s other 12 counties become, the stronger the state.

But the governor also made it clear that he has two primary objectives this legislative session, one is housing and the other is reforming the state’s educational system. We don’t have anywhere close to the homes we need to attract growth, and the educational system we have is too expensive and one whose quality is slipping.

These are less process issues than figuring out how to reduce the number of schools we have and deciding where future housing is most needed and where it can deliver the highest benefit. This is where politics and hard cold truths clash. It’s where long-term planning and the ability to sell the right message is paramount. 

There are 237 towns and 10 cities in Vermont. Not all are equal. History is littered with examples of “investments” made based on political connections, that today lie moribund. In other words, it may not make sense to develop housing projects in Chelsea, but it may in Randolph. Now that the sewer and water line connects Highgate to the Franklin County airport, it may make sense to develop housing there, and not, for example, East Highgate. All counties have their examples of where new housing would work best. Those with updated sewer and water systems should rank higher than those who do not. Those that have local industry should outrank those who don’t. A spreadsheet is needed to show where the public’s investment will have the greatest return. There should be a minimum expectation set. The public’s money should not be used where there is no hope of an adequate return.

That gets us back to Chittenden and Franklin counties. There is a reason this part of the state does better than others. We have a job base. We are near the services people want. We have an international airport. We’re on Lake Champlain and near the Canadian border. We have the University of Vermont. It would be wrong, as well as unproductive, to dismiss our counties because we’ve done comparatively well. 

The state can’t lure newcomers to places they don’t want to be. The process of drawing growth to areas outside our two counties has to be done with care and a certain amount of skepticism. 

To this point, it was also interesting that the governor is calling for a “creative” version of the TIF program to expand housing. That’s a direct reference to the City of St. Albans and its decade-long success in rebuilding its downtown through the TIF program. It’s a recognition that growth does not happen without a public/private partnership that puts up the financing. 

It won’t work everywhere. But using it selectively could be an effective catalyst in many of our counties. 

The challenge is for our legislators to be able and willing to explain to their constituents why this level of decision-making - deciding which town is a better investment than another - is essential to fixing the systems in question. Making the hard choice now doesn’t mean other towns can’t benefit later. But refusing to make those hard choices now makes it almost inevitable that things do not get BETTER.

By Emerson Lynn 

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here